Allesandro Garcia
Mass Shooting at Temple
CLASSIFICATION: Mass Murder
LOCATION
Waddell, Arizona
TIME PERIOD
August 9–10, 1991
VICTIMS
9 confirmed
In the early hours of August 10, 1991, a mass shooting occurred at the Wat Promkunaram Buddhist temple in Waddell, Arizona, resulting in the deaths of nine individuals, including the temple's abbot, five monks, a nun, her nephew, and a temple employee. The victims were all associated with the temple and were either Thai or of Thai descent. The perpetrators, Johnathan Doody and Allesandro Garcia, committed the crime as part of a robbery, using a Stevens 67E 20-gauge shotgun and a Marlin Model 60 .22-caliber rifle. Following the incident, initial arrests were made, but the charges against the "Tucson Four" were dropped after it was revealed that the evidence did not connect them to the crime. As of now, the case remains unresolved, with Doody and Garcia being the only identified suspects, and the investigation continues to seek closure for the victims' families.
Theories surrounding the Waddell Buddhist temple shooting include speculation that the attack was motivated primarily by robbery, given the presence of cash and valuables at the temple. Some believe that the methodical nature of the killings, with victims shot in the back of the head and arranged in a circle, suggests a deeper psychological motive or ritualistic element. Additionally, there are theories about potential connections between the perpetrators and local crime groups, raising questions about whether this was part of a larger pattern of violence targeting places of worship.
The Waddell Buddhist Temple Tragedy: A Tale of Crime and Controversy
The Incident
In the still, early hours of August 10, 1991, an unspeakable tragedy unfolded within the serene confines of Wat Promkunaram, a Thai Buddhist temple in Waddell, Arizona. By dawn, the temple had become the site of what was, at that time, the deadliest mass shooting at a place of worship in U.S. history—a gruesome record that stood until the Charleston church shooting in 2015. Nine lives were lost in this horrific event, cementing the incident as the deadliest mass shooting in Arizona's history as of 2024.
The Crime
The victims, deeply connected to the temple and of Thai descent, included the abbot Pairuch Kanthong, five monks—Surichai Anuttaro, Boochuay Chaiyarach, Chalerm Chantapim, Siang Ginggaeo, and Somsak Sopha—a nun named Foy Sripanpasert, her nephew, novice monk Matthew Miller, and a temple employee named Chirasak Chirapong. Their bodies were discovered later that day by a cook entering the temple. The scene was haunting: each victim had been shot in the back of the head, their bodies arranged face down in a circle. Investigators found 17 spent rifle casings and 4 spent shotgun shells scattered around them.
The Investigation
Initial Arrests
The investigation quickly turned controversial. Four men from Tucson were initially arrested based on a tip from Mike McGraw, a patient at a mental hospital in Tucson, who claimed to know the perpetrators. Despite the lack of concrete evidence linking these men to the crime scene, the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office conducted lengthy interrogations. Three of the four suspects confessed after being subjected to extreme interrogation measures, including being kept awake for over 30 hours. The fourth suspect, however, maintained his innocence, which was later corroborated by video evidence proving he was working miles away at the time of the murders. Consequently, the charges against these men, infamously known as the "Tucson Four," were dropped, sparking widespread criticism of the investigative process.
The Real Perpetrators
The case took a turn when a .22-caliber rifle, identified as one of the murder weapons, was found in the possession of a friend of 17-year-old Johnathan Doody, an ethnic Thai from Thailand. This discovery led investigators to Doody and his accomplice, 16-year-old Allesandro Garcia. According to Garcia's confession, he and Doody had gone to the temple armed with a .22-caliber rifle and a 20-gauge shotgun to commit robbery. The heist netted approximately $2,600 and some audio-visual equipment. Garcia recounted that Doody, fearing recognition by a monk who knew his brother, decided to eliminate all witnesses. Doody allegedly shot each victim in the head, while Garcia fired additional shots into four of the victims' torsos.
Legal Proceedings
Both teenagers faced charges of armed robbery and first-degree murder. In a bid to avoid the death penalty, Garcia pleaded guilty in 1993 and received a sentence of 271 years in prison. Doody was convicted in 1994 and sentenced to 281 years. Garcia later admitted to another murder, that of Alice Cameron, committed two months after the temple massacre, with the assistance of his girlfriend Michelle Hoover.
Doody's conviction, however, was fraught with legal challenges. His defense argued that his confession was coerced, as he had not been properly advised of his rights. The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals overturned his conviction twice, first in 2008 and again in 2011. A retrial in 2013 ended in a mistrial, but a third trial in January 2014 found Doody guilty on all counts. He was sentenced to nine consecutive life terms, and he remains incarcerated at the La Palma Correctional Facility.
Investigation Controversies
The handling of the case by the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office has been scrutinized for its numerous missteps. The initial suspect, Mike McGraw, proved unreliable, having a history of fabricating stories. The investigators' oversight included ignoring critical evidence, such as the murder weapon, which languished untested in their office for weeks. The interrogation techniques used on the Tucson Four, as well as on Doody and Garcia, involved coercion and threats, leading to false confessions.
The fallout from these investigative failures was significant. Lawsuits filed by the wrongfully accused resulted in settlements, and public outrage contributed to the political defeat of Sheriff Tom Agnos by Joe Arpaio in 1992, who campaigned on restoring credibility to the sheriff's office.
Legacy
The Waddell Buddhist temple shooting remains a haunting chapter in Arizona's history. It serves as a stark reminder of the fallibility of justice systems and the devastating impact of investigative errors on individuals and communities. The case also highlights the critical importance of proper legal procedures and the protection of suspect rights to prevent miscarriages of justice.
Sources
No Recent News
No recent news articles found for this case. Check back later for updates.
No Evidence Submitted
No evidence found for this case. Be the first to submit evidence in the comments below.
Join the discussion
Loading comments...
Temple Shooting
A mass shooting at Wat Promkunaram kills nine people.
Victims Found
Bodies of the victims discovered by a cook at the temple.
Initial Arrests
Four men arrested based on a tip from a mental hospital patient.
Charges Dropped
Charges against the Tucson Four are dropped due to lack of evidence.
Focus on Doody and Garcia
Investigation shifts to Johnathan Doody and Allesandro Garcia after finding the murder weapon.
Garcia Pleads Guilty
Allesandro Garcia pleads guilty to avoid death penalty, sentenced to 271 years.
Doody Convicted
Johnathan Doody convicted of nine murders, sentenced to 281 years.
Doody's Retrial
Doody found guilty again in third trial, sentenced to nine life terms.
Sentencing
Doody receives nine consecutive life sentences for the temple murders.
In the early hours of August 10, 1991, a mass shooting occurred at the Wat Promkunaram Buddhist temple in Waddell, Arizona, resulting in the deaths of nine individuals, including the temple's abbot, five monks, a nun, her nephew, and a temple employee. The victims were all associated with the temple and were either Thai or of Thai descent. The perpetrators, Johnathan Doody and Allesandro Garcia, committed the crime as part of a robbery, using a Stevens 67E 20-gauge shotgun and a Marlin Model 60 .22-caliber rifle. Following the incident, initial arrests were made, but the charges against the "Tucson Four" were dropped after it was revealed that the evidence did not connect them to the crime. As of now, the case remains unresolved, with Doody and Garcia being the only identified suspects, and the investigation continues to seek closure for the victims' families.
Theories surrounding the Waddell Buddhist temple shooting include speculation that the attack was motivated primarily by robbery, given the presence of cash and valuables at the temple. Some believe that the methodical nature of the killings, with victims shot in the back of the head and arranged in a circle, suggests a deeper psychological motive or ritualistic element. Additionally, there are theories about potential connections between the perpetrators and local crime groups, raising questions about whether this was part of a larger pattern of violence targeting places of worship.
The Waddell Buddhist Temple Tragedy: A Tale of Crime and Controversy
The Incident
In the still, early hours of August 10, 1991, an unspeakable tragedy unfolded within the serene confines of Wat Promkunaram, a Thai Buddhist temple in Waddell, Arizona. By dawn, the temple had become the site of what was, at that time, the deadliest mass shooting at a place of worship in U.S. history—a gruesome record that stood until the Charleston church shooting in 2015. Nine lives were lost in this horrific event, cementing the incident as the deadliest mass shooting in Arizona's history as of 2024.
The Crime
The victims, deeply connected to the temple and of Thai descent, included the abbot Pairuch Kanthong, five monks—Surichai Anuttaro, Boochuay Chaiyarach, Chalerm Chantapim, Siang Ginggaeo, and Somsak Sopha—a nun named Foy Sripanpasert, her nephew, novice monk Matthew Miller, and a temple employee named Chirasak Chirapong. Their bodies were discovered later that day by a cook entering the temple. The scene was haunting: each victim had been shot in the back of the head, their bodies arranged face down in a circle. Investigators found 17 spent rifle casings and 4 spent shotgun shells scattered around them.
The Investigation
Initial Arrests
The investigation quickly turned controversial. Four men from Tucson were initially arrested based on a tip from Mike McGraw, a patient at a mental hospital in Tucson, who claimed to know the perpetrators. Despite the lack of concrete evidence linking these men to the crime scene, the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office conducted lengthy interrogations. Three of the four suspects confessed after being subjected to extreme interrogation measures, including being kept awake for over 30 hours. The fourth suspect, however, maintained his innocence, which was later corroborated by video evidence proving he was working miles away at the time of the murders. Consequently, the charges against these men, infamously known as the "Tucson Four," were dropped, sparking widespread criticism of the investigative process.
The Real Perpetrators
The case took a turn when a .22-caliber rifle, identified as one of the murder weapons, was found in the possession of a friend of 17-year-old Johnathan Doody, an ethnic Thai from Thailand. This discovery led investigators to Doody and his accomplice, 16-year-old Allesandro Garcia. According to Garcia's confession, he and Doody had gone to the temple armed with a .22-caliber rifle and a 20-gauge shotgun to commit robbery. The heist netted approximately $2,600 and some audio-visual equipment. Garcia recounted that Doody, fearing recognition by a monk who knew his brother, decided to eliminate all witnesses. Doody allegedly shot each victim in the head, while Garcia fired additional shots into four of the victims' torsos.
Legal Proceedings
Both teenagers faced charges of armed robbery and first-degree murder. In a bid to avoid the death penalty, Garcia pleaded guilty in 1993 and received a sentence of 271 years in prison. Doody was convicted in 1994 and sentenced to 281 years. Garcia later admitted to another murder, that of Alice Cameron, committed two months after the temple massacre, with the assistance of his girlfriend Michelle Hoover.
Doody's conviction, however, was fraught with legal challenges. His defense argued that his confession was coerced, as he had not been properly advised of his rights. The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals overturned his conviction twice, first in 2008 and again in 2011. A retrial in 2013 ended in a mistrial, but a third trial in January 2014 found Doody guilty on all counts. He was sentenced to nine consecutive life terms, and he remains incarcerated at the La Palma Correctional Facility.
Investigation Controversies
The handling of the case by the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office has been scrutinized for its numerous missteps. The initial suspect, Mike McGraw, proved unreliable, having a history of fabricating stories. The investigators' oversight included ignoring critical evidence, such as the murder weapon, which languished untested in their office for weeks. The interrogation techniques used on the Tucson Four, as well as on Doody and Garcia, involved coercion and threats, leading to false confessions.
The fallout from these investigative failures was significant. Lawsuits filed by the wrongfully accused resulted in settlements, and public outrage contributed to the political defeat of Sheriff Tom Agnos by Joe Arpaio in 1992, who campaigned on restoring credibility to the sheriff's office.
Legacy
The Waddell Buddhist temple shooting remains a haunting chapter in Arizona's history. It serves as a stark reminder of the fallibility of justice systems and the devastating impact of investigative errors on individuals and communities. The case also highlights the critical importance of proper legal procedures and the protection of suspect rights to prevent miscarriages of justice.
Sources
No Recent News
No recent news articles found for this case. Check back later for updates.
No Evidence Submitted
No evidence found for this case. Be the first to submit evidence in the comments below.
Join the discussion
Loading comments...
Temple Shooting
A mass shooting at Wat Promkunaram kills nine people.
Victims Found
Bodies of the victims discovered by a cook at the temple.
Initial Arrests
Four men arrested based on a tip from a mental hospital patient.
Charges Dropped
Charges against the Tucson Four are dropped due to lack of evidence.
Focus on Doody and Garcia
Investigation shifts to Johnathan Doody and Allesandro Garcia after finding the murder weapon.
Garcia Pleads Guilty
Allesandro Garcia pleads guilty to avoid death penalty, sentenced to 271 years.
Doody Convicted
Johnathan Doody convicted of nine murders, sentenced to 281 years.
Doody's Retrial
Doody found guilty again in third trial, sentenced to nine life terms.
Sentencing
Doody receives nine consecutive life sentences for the temple murders.