David Nathaniel Anderson
Mass Shooting Incident
CLASSIFICATION: Mass Murder
LOCATION
Jersey City, New Jersey
TIME PERIOD
December 10, 2019
VICTIMS
7 confirmed
On December 10, 2019, a mass shooting occurred at the JC Kosher Supermarket in the Greenville section of Jersey City, New Jersey, resulting in the deaths of three individuals and injuries to three others, including two police officers. The assailants, David N. Anderson and Francine Graham, were killed during a shootout with law enforcement following the attack. Prior to the supermarket incident, Anderson had fatally shot a Jersey City Police Department detective at a nearby cemetery during a chance encounter. The attack was motivated by antisemitism and anti-law enforcement sentiment, with evidence suggesting that a larger plot had been planned but was disrupted by the detective's intervention. The case is classified as a hate crime and domestic terrorism, highlighting a concerning trend of violence against Jewish communities in the U.S.
The shooting at the kosher grocery store is believed by some to be a targeted hate crime against the Jewish community, as the assailants had ties to extremist groups. Others speculate that the attack was part of a larger pattern of domestic terrorism linked to anti-Semitic violence. Additionally, some investigators are examining the possibility of a broader conspiracy involving the assailants' motives and connections to other violent acts.
The 2019 Jersey City Shooting: A Day of Terror
Prelude to Violence
On a frigid day in December 2019, Jersey City, New Jersey, became the backdrop for a chilling tale of hate-fueled violence. The events of December 10, 2019, began in the seemingly innocuous surroundings of Bayview Cemetery. It was here that Detective Joseph Seals, a respected officer of the Jersey City Police Department, fatefully crossed paths with David Nathaniel Anderson and Francine Graham. The pair, who were entrenched in a world of antisemitism and anti-law enforcement sentiment, were sitting in a stolen U-Haul van linked to a recent murder.
This chance encounter proved deadly as Anderson and Graham fatally shot Detective Seals. His lifeless body was discovered at 12:38 p.m. by a passerby, marking the beginning of a three-hour wave of terror that would reverberate far beyond Jersey City's borders.
The Attack Unfolds
Having fled the cemetery, Anderson and Graham drove the van to the JC Kosher Supermarket located at 223 Martin Luther King Drive. Without hesitation, they exited the vehicle and launched a targeted assault on the store, pointedly ignoring bystanders on the street. Armed with an arsenal that included an AR-15-style rifle and a Mossberg 12-gauge shotgun, the assailants burst into the market, their tactical gear turning the space into a battleground.
Within minutes, three innocent lives were lost: Mindy Ferencz, the 33-year-old store owner and mother of three; Douglas Miguel Rodriguez, a 49-year-old employee originally from Ecuador who was heroically holding the back door open for others to escape; and Moshe Deutsch, a 24-year-old rabbinical student and customer. The attackers' rampage left others injured, including two police officers whose injuries were mercifully non-fatal.
The chaotic scene extended into a protracted siege, culminating in a shootout with police that lasted for hours. The exchange ended only when a BearCat armored personnel carrier breached the storefront, bringing the violent episode to a close. Hundreds of shell casings littered the scene, a stark testament to the ferocity of the gunfire.
The Assailants
David Anderson, 47, and Francine Graham, 50, were no strangers to violence. Their criminal activities had begun days earlier with the murder of Uber driver Michael Rumberger in Bayonne, New Jersey. Investigators uncovered a Bible stained with Rumberger's blood and his DNA on the assailants' clothing and weapons. This gruesome discovery was part of a broader investigation that revealed Anderson and Graham's history of antisemitic and anti-police sentiments. Anderson, a self-identified Black Hebrew Israelite, had been vocal on social media, spreading messages of hate and conspiracy.
Their preparations for the attack on the JC Kosher Supermarket were meticulous. Surveillance footage showed the pair scouting the location on multiple occasions, and authorities later determined that they had planned the assault for months. The couple's arsenal was extensive, including a .22-caliber Ruger Mark IV handgun with a homemade silencer and a pipe bomb capable of causing mass casualties, though it was never detonated. They had even lined their van with homemade ballistic panels crafted from bulletproof vest materials.
The Motive
The motive behind the attack was rooted in a toxic mix of antisemitism and a deep-seated hatred for law enforcement. Attorney General of New Jersey Gurbir Grewal classified the incident as an act of domestic terrorism, driven by prejudice against the Jewish community and law enforcement. This attack was part of a disturbing trend of violence against Jews in the United States, a fact underscored by the presence of a Jewish day school with 50 students in the same building as the supermarket.
The attackers' intentions were even more chilling. Evidence suggested they had planned larger attacks against both the Jewish community and law enforcement. Detective Seals's unexpected encounter with them at the cemetery may have disrupted these plans, potentially saving countless lives.
The Aftermath
The tragic events prompted widespread condemnation and an outpouring of grief. President Donald Trump, New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy, and other officials expressed their condolences to the victims' families. Meanwhile, the community struggled to come to terms with the violence that had shattered their sense of safety.
In the following days, tensions flared. Jersey City Board of Education trustee Joan Terrell-Paige faced calls to resign after posting controversial comments on Facebook that were seen as insensitive in the wake of the attack. The incident also sparked broader discussions about antisemitism and domestic terrorism, highlighting the ongoing threat posed by ideologically driven violence.
By March 2020, the JC Kosher Supermarket had reopened at a new location, a symbol of resilience in the face of hate. The legal aftermath continued, with a pawn shop dealer linked to the assailants pleading guilty to weapons charges, and a grand jury later ruling the police's actions during the siege as justified.
In 2022, a memorial bench was dedicated to Detective Joseph A. Seals at 16th Street Park in Bayonne, ensuring that his bravery and sacrifice would not be forgotten.
Sources
For more detailed information, please refer to the original Wikipedia article: 2019 Jersey City shooting.
No Recent News
No recent news articles found for this case. Check back later for updates.
No Evidence Submitted
No evidence found for this case. Be the first to submit evidence in the comments below.
Join the discussion
Loading comments...
Murder of Michael Rumberger
Uber driver Michael Rumberger is murdered by the assailants, David Anderson and Francine Graham.
Detective Seals Killed
Detective Joseph Seals is shot and killed by the assailants at Bayview Cemetery while investigating.
Kosher Grocery Shooting
Anderson and Graham attack JC Kosher Supermarket, killing three and injuring others in a hate-fueled assault.
Shootout with Police
A prolonged shootout occurs between the assailants and police, lasting over three hours before the assailants are killed.
Assailants Identified
David Anderson and Francine Graham are identified as the shooters involved in the Jersey City attack.
Evidence of Planned Attack
Investigators reveal that Anderson and Graham had planned a larger attack targeting the Jewish community.
Bomb Details Released
Authorities disclose that a live pipe bomb was found in the assailants' van, capable of causing mass casualties.
Market Reopens
The JC Kosher Supermarket reopens at a new location three months after the shooting incident.
Grand Jury Decision
A grand jury clears officers involved in the shootout with the Jersey City assailants, ruling their actions justified.
Memorial for Detective Seals
A memorial celebration is held to honor the late Detective Joseph A. Seals.
On December 10, 2019, a mass shooting occurred at the JC Kosher Supermarket in the Greenville section of Jersey City, New Jersey, resulting in the deaths of three individuals and injuries to three others, including two police officers. The assailants, David N. Anderson and Francine Graham, were killed during a shootout with law enforcement following the attack. Prior to the supermarket incident, Anderson had fatally shot a Jersey City Police Department detective at a nearby cemetery during a chance encounter. The attack was motivated by antisemitism and anti-law enforcement sentiment, with evidence suggesting that a larger plot had been planned but was disrupted by the detective's intervention. The case is classified as a hate crime and domestic terrorism, highlighting a concerning trend of violence against Jewish communities in the U.S.
The shooting at the kosher grocery store is believed by some to be a targeted hate crime against the Jewish community, as the assailants had ties to extremist groups. Others speculate that the attack was part of a larger pattern of domestic terrorism linked to anti-Semitic violence. Additionally, some investigators are examining the possibility of a broader conspiracy involving the assailants' motives and connections to other violent acts.
The 2019 Jersey City Shooting: A Day of Terror
Prelude to Violence
On a frigid day in December 2019, Jersey City, New Jersey, became the backdrop for a chilling tale of hate-fueled violence. The events of December 10, 2019, began in the seemingly innocuous surroundings of Bayview Cemetery. It was here that Detective Joseph Seals, a respected officer of the Jersey City Police Department, fatefully crossed paths with David Nathaniel Anderson and Francine Graham. The pair, who were entrenched in a world of antisemitism and anti-law enforcement sentiment, were sitting in a stolen U-Haul van linked to a recent murder.
This chance encounter proved deadly as Anderson and Graham fatally shot Detective Seals. His lifeless body was discovered at 12:38 p.m. by a passerby, marking the beginning of a three-hour wave of terror that would reverberate far beyond Jersey City's borders.
The Attack Unfolds
Having fled the cemetery, Anderson and Graham drove the van to the JC Kosher Supermarket located at 223 Martin Luther King Drive. Without hesitation, they exited the vehicle and launched a targeted assault on the store, pointedly ignoring bystanders on the street. Armed with an arsenal that included an AR-15-style rifle and a Mossberg 12-gauge shotgun, the assailants burst into the market, their tactical gear turning the space into a battleground.
Within minutes, three innocent lives were lost: Mindy Ferencz, the 33-year-old store owner and mother of three; Douglas Miguel Rodriguez, a 49-year-old employee originally from Ecuador who was heroically holding the back door open for others to escape; and Moshe Deutsch, a 24-year-old rabbinical student and customer. The attackers' rampage left others injured, including two police officers whose injuries were mercifully non-fatal.
The chaotic scene extended into a protracted siege, culminating in a shootout with police that lasted for hours. The exchange ended only when a BearCat armored personnel carrier breached the storefront, bringing the violent episode to a close. Hundreds of shell casings littered the scene, a stark testament to the ferocity of the gunfire.
The Assailants
David Anderson, 47, and Francine Graham, 50, were no strangers to violence. Their criminal activities had begun days earlier with the murder of Uber driver Michael Rumberger in Bayonne, New Jersey. Investigators uncovered a Bible stained with Rumberger's blood and his DNA on the assailants' clothing and weapons. This gruesome discovery was part of a broader investigation that revealed Anderson and Graham's history of antisemitic and anti-police sentiments. Anderson, a self-identified Black Hebrew Israelite, had been vocal on social media, spreading messages of hate and conspiracy.
Their preparations for the attack on the JC Kosher Supermarket were meticulous. Surveillance footage showed the pair scouting the location on multiple occasions, and authorities later determined that they had planned the assault for months. The couple's arsenal was extensive, including a .22-caliber Ruger Mark IV handgun with a homemade silencer and a pipe bomb capable of causing mass casualties, though it was never detonated. They had even lined their van with homemade ballistic panels crafted from bulletproof vest materials.
The Motive
The motive behind the attack was rooted in a toxic mix of antisemitism and a deep-seated hatred for law enforcement. Attorney General of New Jersey Gurbir Grewal classified the incident as an act of domestic terrorism, driven by prejudice against the Jewish community and law enforcement. This attack was part of a disturbing trend of violence against Jews in the United States, a fact underscored by the presence of a Jewish day school with 50 students in the same building as the supermarket.
The attackers' intentions were even more chilling. Evidence suggested they had planned larger attacks against both the Jewish community and law enforcement. Detective Seals's unexpected encounter with them at the cemetery may have disrupted these plans, potentially saving countless lives.
The Aftermath
The tragic events prompted widespread condemnation and an outpouring of grief. President Donald Trump, New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy, and other officials expressed their condolences to the victims' families. Meanwhile, the community struggled to come to terms with the violence that had shattered their sense of safety.
In the following days, tensions flared. Jersey City Board of Education trustee Joan Terrell-Paige faced calls to resign after posting controversial comments on Facebook that were seen as insensitive in the wake of the attack. The incident also sparked broader discussions about antisemitism and domestic terrorism, highlighting the ongoing threat posed by ideologically driven violence.
By March 2020, the JC Kosher Supermarket had reopened at a new location, a symbol of resilience in the face of hate. The legal aftermath continued, with a pawn shop dealer linked to the assailants pleading guilty to weapons charges, and a grand jury later ruling the police's actions during the siege as justified.
In 2022, a memorial bench was dedicated to Detective Joseph A. Seals at 16th Street Park in Bayonne, ensuring that his bravery and sacrifice would not be forgotten.
Sources
For more detailed information, please refer to the original Wikipedia article: 2019 Jersey City shooting.
No Recent News
No recent news articles found for this case. Check back later for updates.
No Evidence Submitted
No evidence found for this case. Be the first to submit evidence in the comments below.
Join the discussion
Loading comments...
Murder of Michael Rumberger
Uber driver Michael Rumberger is murdered by the assailants, David Anderson and Francine Graham.
Detective Seals Killed
Detective Joseph Seals is shot and killed by the assailants at Bayview Cemetery while investigating.
Kosher Grocery Shooting
Anderson and Graham attack JC Kosher Supermarket, killing three and injuring others in a hate-fueled assault.
Shootout with Police
A prolonged shootout occurs between the assailants and police, lasting over three hours before the assailants are killed.
Assailants Identified
David Anderson and Francine Graham are identified as the shooters involved in the Jersey City attack.
Evidence of Planned Attack
Investigators reveal that Anderson and Graham had planned a larger attack targeting the Jewish community.
Bomb Details Released
Authorities disclose that a live pipe bomb was found in the assailants' van, capable of causing mass casualties.
Market Reopens
The JC Kosher Supermarket reopens at a new location three months after the shooting incident.
Grand Jury Decision
A grand jury clears officers involved in the shootout with the Jersey City assailants, ruling their actions justified.
Memorial for Detective Seals
A memorial celebration is held to honor the late Detective Joseph A. Seals.