Esek Hopkins
Controversial Naval Commander Case
CLASSIFICATION: Mass Murder
LOCATION
Nassau, Bahamas
TIME PERIOD
March 3, 1776
VICTIMS
109 confirmed
Commodore Esek Hopkins, a prominent officer in the Continental Navy during the American Revolutionary War, was appointed as the only commander-in-chief of the Continental Navy by the Continental Congress on December 22, 1775. His notable military action included the successful raid on Nassau in the Bahamas, where he captured significant military supplies. Born on April 26, 1718, in Scituate, Rhode Island, and passing away on February 26, 1802, in Providence, Hopkins' legacy is marred by his involvement in the Atlantic slave trade and allegations of torturing British prisoners of war during his service. Currently, his contributions to naval warfare are recognized, but his controversial actions have led to a complex historical evaluation of his legacy.
Esek Hopkins is believed by some to have had a significant impact on the Atlantic slave trade, as he commanded a slave ship before his naval career. Additionally, there are claims that he was involved in the torture of British prisoners of war, which has contributed to a controversial legacy that complicates his status as a naval hero. Some speculate that his actions during the Revolutionary War may overshadow his contributions to American independence due to these darker aspects of his history.
The Complicated Legacy of Esek Hopkins: A Revolutionary Tale
Early Life and Maritime Beginnings
Born on April 26, 1718, in Scituate, within the Colony of Rhode Island and Providence Plantations, Esek Hopkins hailed from one of the most influential families in what is now Rhode Island. At the tender age of twenty, Hopkins embarked on a life at sea, quickly establishing himself as a deft sailor and astute trader. His nautical prowess was honed through voyages to nearly every corner of the globe, and he commanded a privateer during the tumultuous French and Indian War. Between these seafaring adventures, Hopkins was deeply involved in Rhode Island politics, serving as a deputy in the Rhode Island General Assembly and supporting his brother, Stephen Hopkins, who assumed the governorship in 1755.
In September 1764, Hopkins took the helm of the slave ship Sally, owned by Nicholas Brown and Company. Despite his lack of experience in the slave trade, Hopkins's 15-month voyage was marked by tragedy, resulting in the deaths of 109 out of 196 slaves on board. When the Sally reached the West Indies in late 1765, the condition of the surviving slaves was so dire that they sold for minimal profit. This disastrous venture contributed to Moses Brown's eventual opposition to the slave trade.
Rising to Commodore
Hopkins's reputation as a capable leader led to his appointment as a brigadier general to command all military forces of Rhode Island on October 4, 1775. He swiftly bolstered the colony's defenses with the aid of his deputy, William West. On December 22, 1775, the Continental Congress elevated Hopkins to Commander in Chief of the nascent Continental Navy, charging him with defending American commerce.
On January 5, 1776, Congress issued Hopkins his orders, instructing him to set sail with utmost urgency. If feasible, he was to head toward Chesapeake Bay in Virginia, assess British naval strength, and, if advantageous, engage and destroy enemy forces there. Should conditions prevent fulfilling these orders, Hopkins was granted the discretion to pursue actions that would best serve the American cause.
Armed with eight modified merchant ships from Philadelphia, Hopkins faced the daunting task of confronting formidable British forces. Opting to seize a strategic advantage, he set sail on February 17, 1776, targeting the Bahamas rather than the Chesapeake Bay. His decision was driven by the opportunity to capture valuable resources for the Continental Army, recognizing Nassau's weak defenses and leveraging local allies.
The Raid of Nassau
On March 3, 1776, Hopkins orchestrated the first U.S. amphibious assault, known as the Raid of Nassau. Marines and sailors executed a daring operation, capturing munitions vital to the War of Independence. The fleet returned to New London on April 8, 1776, having seized two British merchantmen and severely damaged HMS Glasgow, though failing to capture it.
John Hancock, President of the Continental Congress, praised Hopkins's success, noting the bravery and spirit of his men. The raid not only secured essential supplies but also forced the British to divert their naval resources, easing pressure on the American colonies. Notably, John Paul Jones served as a lieutenant under Hopkins during this period.
Controversies and Challenges
Despite the raid's success, Hopkins's deviation from his original orders sparked discontent among southern members of the Continental Congress. The growing tensions highlighted the political, social, economic, religious, and philosophical divisions within the Congress.
The Congress authorized private ships to engage British vessels through letters of marque, allowing privateers to claim spoils, thus paying their crews double the wages of the Continental Navy. Even with additional ships provided by Congress, Hopkins struggled to assemble adequate crews. Defenders like John Adams and Benjamin Franklin supported Hopkins, but the political climate grew increasingly hostile.
On August 12, 1776, Congress censured Hopkins, tarnishing his reputation. Though some believed he should have been relieved of command immediately, he continued to serve. Nevertheless, his fleet remained largely blockaded in Narragansett Bay due to British naval superiority.
Amid mounting criticism, Hopkins faced allegations of torturing British prisoners, brought forth by whistleblowers Richard Marven and Samuel Shaw. Though these claims contributed to his dismissal, they also led Congress to affirm the duty of individuals to report misconduct, shaping early whistleblower protections.
Final Years and Legacy
On January 2, 1778, the Continental Congress permanently relieved Hopkins of his command. Although his initial raid on Nassau proved strategically significant, it was politically weaponized against him. John Paul Jones, once under Hopkins's command, later gained renown employing similar tactics against the British Navy.
After his dismissal, Hopkins remained a respected figure in Rhode Island, serving in the General Assembly until 1786. He retired to his farm, where he passed away on February 26, 1802. His home, the Esek Hopkins House, now holds a place on the National Register of Historic Places.
Hopkins's legacy is multifaceted. Three U.S. Navy vessels have borne his name, and a statue by Theo Alice Ruggles Kitson stands in Providence. Yet, his association with the slave ship Sally led to the removal of his name from a middle school in 2020. Hopkins popularized the "Gadsden flag," a symbol of American defiance, flying it from his flagship USS Alfred.
Personal Life
In November 1741, Hopkins married Desire Burroughs, strengthening his ties to Rhode Island's elite. Together, they had nine children, including John Burroughs Hopkins, a Continental Navy captain involved in the Gaspee Affair, and Susannah Hopkins, who married Baptist minister Jonathan Maxcy.
Esek Hopkins was buried in Providence's North Burial Ground. His life remains a testament to the complexities and contradictions of America's early naval history.
Sources
For more detailed information, visit the Wikipedia page on Esek Hopkins.
No Recent News
No recent news articles found for this case. Check back later for updates.
No Evidence Submitted
No evidence found for this case. Be the first to submit evidence in the comments below.
Join the discussion
Loading comments...
Esek Hopkins Born
Esek Hopkins is born in Scituate, Rhode Island.
Appointed Commander-in-Chief
Continental Congress appoints Hopkins as Commander-in-Chief of the Continental Navy.
First Fleet Operation
Hopkins sails south for the first U.S. fleet operation to Nassau, Bahamas.
Raid of Nassau
Hopkins leads a successful raid on Nassau, capturing military supplies.
Congress Censures Hopkins
The Continental Congress censures Hopkins, damaging his reputation.
Relieved of Command
Continental Congress votes to relieve Hopkins of his command permanently.
Esek Hopkins Dies
Esek Hopkins passes away in Providence, Rhode Island.
Commodore Esek Hopkins, a prominent officer in the Continental Navy during the American Revolutionary War, was appointed as the only commander-in-chief of the Continental Navy by the Continental Congress on December 22, 1775. His notable military action included the successful raid on Nassau in the Bahamas, where he captured significant military supplies. Born on April 26, 1718, in Scituate, Rhode Island, and passing away on February 26, 1802, in Providence, Hopkins' legacy is marred by his involvement in the Atlantic slave trade and allegations of torturing British prisoners of war during his service. Currently, his contributions to naval warfare are recognized, but his controversial actions have led to a complex historical evaluation of his legacy.
Esek Hopkins is believed by some to have had a significant impact on the Atlantic slave trade, as he commanded a slave ship before his naval career. Additionally, there are claims that he was involved in the torture of British prisoners of war, which has contributed to a controversial legacy that complicates his status as a naval hero. Some speculate that his actions during the Revolutionary War may overshadow his contributions to American independence due to these darker aspects of his history.
The Complicated Legacy of Esek Hopkins: A Revolutionary Tale
Early Life and Maritime Beginnings
Born on April 26, 1718, in Scituate, within the Colony of Rhode Island and Providence Plantations, Esek Hopkins hailed from one of the most influential families in what is now Rhode Island. At the tender age of twenty, Hopkins embarked on a life at sea, quickly establishing himself as a deft sailor and astute trader. His nautical prowess was honed through voyages to nearly every corner of the globe, and he commanded a privateer during the tumultuous French and Indian War. Between these seafaring adventures, Hopkins was deeply involved in Rhode Island politics, serving as a deputy in the Rhode Island General Assembly and supporting his brother, Stephen Hopkins, who assumed the governorship in 1755.
In September 1764, Hopkins took the helm of the slave ship Sally, owned by Nicholas Brown and Company. Despite his lack of experience in the slave trade, Hopkins's 15-month voyage was marked by tragedy, resulting in the deaths of 109 out of 196 slaves on board. When the Sally reached the West Indies in late 1765, the condition of the surviving slaves was so dire that they sold for minimal profit. This disastrous venture contributed to Moses Brown's eventual opposition to the slave trade.
Rising to Commodore
Hopkins's reputation as a capable leader led to his appointment as a brigadier general to command all military forces of Rhode Island on October 4, 1775. He swiftly bolstered the colony's defenses with the aid of his deputy, William West. On December 22, 1775, the Continental Congress elevated Hopkins to Commander in Chief of the nascent Continental Navy, charging him with defending American commerce.
On January 5, 1776, Congress issued Hopkins his orders, instructing him to set sail with utmost urgency. If feasible, he was to head toward Chesapeake Bay in Virginia, assess British naval strength, and, if advantageous, engage and destroy enemy forces there. Should conditions prevent fulfilling these orders, Hopkins was granted the discretion to pursue actions that would best serve the American cause.
Armed with eight modified merchant ships from Philadelphia, Hopkins faced the daunting task of confronting formidable British forces. Opting to seize a strategic advantage, he set sail on February 17, 1776, targeting the Bahamas rather than the Chesapeake Bay. His decision was driven by the opportunity to capture valuable resources for the Continental Army, recognizing Nassau's weak defenses and leveraging local allies.
The Raid of Nassau
On March 3, 1776, Hopkins orchestrated the first U.S. amphibious assault, known as the Raid of Nassau. Marines and sailors executed a daring operation, capturing munitions vital to the War of Independence. The fleet returned to New London on April 8, 1776, having seized two British merchantmen and severely damaged HMS Glasgow, though failing to capture it.
John Hancock, President of the Continental Congress, praised Hopkins's success, noting the bravery and spirit of his men. The raid not only secured essential supplies but also forced the British to divert their naval resources, easing pressure on the American colonies. Notably, John Paul Jones served as a lieutenant under Hopkins during this period.
Controversies and Challenges
Despite the raid's success, Hopkins's deviation from his original orders sparked discontent among southern members of the Continental Congress. The growing tensions highlighted the political, social, economic, religious, and philosophical divisions within the Congress.
The Congress authorized private ships to engage British vessels through letters of marque, allowing privateers to claim spoils, thus paying their crews double the wages of the Continental Navy. Even with additional ships provided by Congress, Hopkins struggled to assemble adequate crews. Defenders like John Adams and Benjamin Franklin supported Hopkins, but the political climate grew increasingly hostile.
On August 12, 1776, Congress censured Hopkins, tarnishing his reputation. Though some believed he should have been relieved of command immediately, he continued to serve. Nevertheless, his fleet remained largely blockaded in Narragansett Bay due to British naval superiority.
Amid mounting criticism, Hopkins faced allegations of torturing British prisoners, brought forth by whistleblowers Richard Marven and Samuel Shaw. Though these claims contributed to his dismissal, they also led Congress to affirm the duty of individuals to report misconduct, shaping early whistleblower protections.
Final Years and Legacy
On January 2, 1778, the Continental Congress permanently relieved Hopkins of his command. Although his initial raid on Nassau proved strategically significant, it was politically weaponized against him. John Paul Jones, once under Hopkins's command, later gained renown employing similar tactics against the British Navy.
After his dismissal, Hopkins remained a respected figure in Rhode Island, serving in the General Assembly until 1786. He retired to his farm, where he passed away on February 26, 1802. His home, the Esek Hopkins House, now holds a place on the National Register of Historic Places.
Hopkins's legacy is multifaceted. Three U.S. Navy vessels have borne his name, and a statue by Theo Alice Ruggles Kitson stands in Providence. Yet, his association with the slave ship Sally led to the removal of his name from a middle school in 2020. Hopkins popularized the "Gadsden flag," a symbol of American defiance, flying it from his flagship USS Alfred.
Personal Life
In November 1741, Hopkins married Desire Burroughs, strengthening his ties to Rhode Island's elite. Together, they had nine children, including John Burroughs Hopkins, a Continental Navy captain involved in the Gaspee Affair, and Susannah Hopkins, who married Baptist minister Jonathan Maxcy.
Esek Hopkins was buried in Providence's North Burial Ground. His life remains a testament to the complexities and contradictions of America's early naval history.
Sources
For more detailed information, visit the Wikipedia page on Esek Hopkins.
No Recent News
No recent news articles found for this case. Check back later for updates.
No Evidence Submitted
No evidence found for this case. Be the first to submit evidence in the comments below.
Join the discussion
Loading comments...
Esek Hopkins Born
Esek Hopkins is born in Scituate, Rhode Island.
Appointed Commander-in-Chief
Continental Congress appoints Hopkins as Commander-in-Chief of the Continental Navy.
First Fleet Operation
Hopkins sails south for the first U.S. fleet operation to Nassau, Bahamas.
Raid of Nassau
Hopkins leads a successful raid on Nassau, capturing military supplies.
Congress Censures Hopkins
The Continental Congress censures Hopkins, damaging his reputation.
Relieved of Command
Continental Congress votes to relieve Hopkins of his command permanently.
Esek Hopkins Dies
Esek Hopkins passes away in Providence, Rhode Island.