Eugene McWatters
Florida Serial Killer
CLASSIFICATION: Serial Homicide
LOCATION
Port Salerno, Florida
TIME PERIOD
2003-2004
VICTIMS
3 confirmed
Eugene Wayman McWatters Jr., known as "The Salerno Strangler," was a serial killer who targeted homeless women in Port Salerno, Florida, between December 15, 2003, and May 31, 2004. He was responsible for the murders of three victims, including Jackie Bradley, whom he strangled and disposed of in a ditch, and Christal Wiggins, whose body was found in a pile of brush. McWatters was apprehended on June 23, 2004, and initially sentenced to death in 2006; however, his sentence was commuted to life imprisonment in 2014 due to a technicality. Significant evidence included witness testimonies and forensic analysis linking him to the crime scenes, although he was not initially questioned despite being identified as a person of interest. McWatters died in custody on September 9, 2024.
Investigators and the public believe that Eugene McWatters may have targeted homeless women due to their vulnerability, suggesting a calculated choice in his victims. Some speculate that his history of violence and criminal behavior indicates a pattern of escalating aggression leading to his serial killings. Additionally, there is speculation about possible connections to other unsolved cases in the area, with some theorizing that he might have been involved in more crimes than those for which he was convicted.
The Dark Path of Eugene McWatters: The Salerno Strangler
Early Life and Troubled Beginnings
Eugene Wayman McWatters Jr., born on June 20, 1978, in Port Salerno, Florida, seemed destined for a life far removed from notoriety. Yet, his path took a dark turn early on. After dropping out of high school, McWatters struggled with a drug habit that made stable employment elusive. This led him to a series of low-skilled jobs and eventually into the grasp of the law.
In January 1998, McWatters' escalating violence became evident when he was arrested for aggravated battery against a teenage boy. He pleaded no contest, serving seven months of a prison sentence before his release on probation. But the law was not done with McWatters. In 2001, he was arrested again, this time for injuring his girlfriend's father with a gun. A mere three months behind bars for probation violation followed.
McWatters' brushes with the law continued into 2002, with an arrest for assaulting his landlord's son—a charge eventually dropped due to lack of evidence. That November, he was apprehended once more for robbing a man of his necklace. The charge was similarly abandoned when the victim left the country without cooperating. McWatters' criminal activities persisted into August 2003 when he was caught robbing a woman's car, only to be released due to the victim’s refusal to cooperate.
The Murders Begin
The sinister transformation of Eugene McWatters into the "Salerno Strangler" began on December 15, 2003. Under the shadows of a campsite in Golden Gate, he raped a homeless woman who, out of fear or despair, chose not to report the crime. The chilling pattern escalated on March 24, 2004, when McWatters attacked 43-year-old Jackie Bradley. The assault ended in her death by strangulation. He disposed of her body in a ditch with shallow water, attempting to obscure it beneath rocks. A jogger discovered the body a week later, sparking an investigation that would eventually point to McWatters, though initially, the police failed to pursue him aggressively.
The violence continued on May 31, 2004, when McWatters picked up 29-year-old Christal Wiggins, a prostitute, and ended her life through strangulation. He discarded her body in a pile of brush. Just hours later, he struck again, this time claiming the life of 18-year-old Carrie Ann Caughey. After strangling her, McWatters attempted to hide Caughey's body under a pile of branches but clumsily tripped and broke his foot.
Caughey's body was found by passersby on June 4, 2004. By then, the authorities suspected a link between her murder and Bradley’s death. The discovery of Wiggins' body on June 7, 2004, confirmed the string of murders. Investigators connected McWatters to the crimes when they learned he sought medical treatment for a broken foot. The woman he raped in 2003 came forward, identifying him in a photo lineup. McWatters was arrested the following day and confessed to the murders, only to later retract his confession.
Trials and Imprisonment
The courtroom lights bore down on McWatters in September 2006 as his trial commenced. Prosecutors painted him as a calculating predator who lured vulnerable women with the promise of drugs and alcohol. His defense team argued that McWatters' confession was a ploy for attention, denying his guilt in the killings. The jury was not convinced. On December 4, 2006, McWatters was found guilty of three counts of first-degree murder and sentenced to death.
For eight years, McWatters languished on death row until 2014, when a judge granted him a new trial, citing ineffective representation by his original defense team. In this new trial, McWatters pleaded no contest, resulting in his sentence being commuted to life imprisonment in 2015. The Salerno Strangler's story ended behind bars, with his death on September 9, 2024, at the Central Florida Reception Center in Orlando, Florida.
Sources
- The Palm Beach Post - Prosecution lays out case against McWatters
- WFLX.com - Eugene McWatters, man dubbed Salerno Strangler, sentenced to 3 life terms
- The Palm Beach Post - Eugene McWatters no stranger to police; The McWatters timeline
- The Palm Beach Post - Victim of December rape ID'd suspect from lineup
- Scripps Treasure Coast Newspapers - 'Salerno Strangler' seeks new trial, says original attorneys were ineffective
- The Palm Beach Post - 'Salerno Strangler' pleads no contest to first-degree murder
- Florida Department of Corrections
For further exploration of the chilling narrative, visit Wikipedia’s entry on Eugene McWatters.
No Recent News
No recent news articles found for this case. Check back later for updates.
No Evidence Submitted
No evidence found for this case. Be the first to submit evidence in the comments below.
Join the discussion
Loading comments...
First Rape Incident
Eugene McWatters rapes a homeless woman at a campsite.
First Murder
McWatters strangles and kills Jackie Bradley, dumping her body in a ditch.
Body Discovered
The body of Jackie Bradley is found by a jogger.
Second and Third Murders
McWatters strangles Christal Wiggins and Carrie Ann Caughey on the same day.
Caughey's Body Found
The body of Carrie Ann Caughey is discovered by passersby.
Wiggins' Body Found
The body of Christal Wiggins is discovered, linking her to the murders.
Arrest of McWatters
McWatters is arrested after being identified by a rape victim.
Sentenced to Death
McWatters is found guilty and sentenced to death for three murders.
Sentence Commuted
McWatters' death sentence is commuted to life imprisonment after a retrial.
Death in Prison
Eugene McWatters dies in prison.
Eugene Wayman McWatters Jr., known as "The Salerno Strangler," was a serial killer who targeted homeless women in Port Salerno, Florida, between December 15, 2003, and May 31, 2004. He was responsible for the murders of three victims, including Jackie Bradley, whom he strangled and disposed of in a ditch, and Christal Wiggins, whose body was found in a pile of brush. McWatters was apprehended on June 23, 2004, and initially sentenced to death in 2006; however, his sentence was commuted to life imprisonment in 2014 due to a technicality. Significant evidence included witness testimonies and forensic analysis linking him to the crime scenes, although he was not initially questioned despite being identified as a person of interest. McWatters died in custody on September 9, 2024.
Investigators and the public believe that Eugene McWatters may have targeted homeless women due to their vulnerability, suggesting a calculated choice in his victims. Some speculate that his history of violence and criminal behavior indicates a pattern of escalating aggression leading to his serial killings. Additionally, there is speculation about possible connections to other unsolved cases in the area, with some theorizing that he might have been involved in more crimes than those for which he was convicted.
The Dark Path of Eugene McWatters: The Salerno Strangler
Early Life and Troubled Beginnings
Eugene Wayman McWatters Jr., born on June 20, 1978, in Port Salerno, Florida, seemed destined for a life far removed from notoriety. Yet, his path took a dark turn early on. After dropping out of high school, McWatters struggled with a drug habit that made stable employment elusive. This led him to a series of low-skilled jobs and eventually into the grasp of the law.
In January 1998, McWatters' escalating violence became evident when he was arrested for aggravated battery against a teenage boy. He pleaded no contest, serving seven months of a prison sentence before his release on probation. But the law was not done with McWatters. In 2001, he was arrested again, this time for injuring his girlfriend's father with a gun. A mere three months behind bars for probation violation followed.
McWatters' brushes with the law continued into 2002, with an arrest for assaulting his landlord's son—a charge eventually dropped due to lack of evidence. That November, he was apprehended once more for robbing a man of his necklace. The charge was similarly abandoned when the victim left the country without cooperating. McWatters' criminal activities persisted into August 2003 when he was caught robbing a woman's car, only to be released due to the victim’s refusal to cooperate.
The Murders Begin
The sinister transformation of Eugene McWatters into the "Salerno Strangler" began on December 15, 2003. Under the shadows of a campsite in Golden Gate, he raped a homeless woman who, out of fear or despair, chose not to report the crime. The chilling pattern escalated on March 24, 2004, when McWatters attacked 43-year-old Jackie Bradley. The assault ended in her death by strangulation. He disposed of her body in a ditch with shallow water, attempting to obscure it beneath rocks. A jogger discovered the body a week later, sparking an investigation that would eventually point to McWatters, though initially, the police failed to pursue him aggressively.
The violence continued on May 31, 2004, when McWatters picked up 29-year-old Christal Wiggins, a prostitute, and ended her life through strangulation. He discarded her body in a pile of brush. Just hours later, he struck again, this time claiming the life of 18-year-old Carrie Ann Caughey. After strangling her, McWatters attempted to hide Caughey's body under a pile of branches but clumsily tripped and broke his foot.
Caughey's body was found by passersby on June 4, 2004. By then, the authorities suspected a link between her murder and Bradley’s death. The discovery of Wiggins' body on June 7, 2004, confirmed the string of murders. Investigators connected McWatters to the crimes when they learned he sought medical treatment for a broken foot. The woman he raped in 2003 came forward, identifying him in a photo lineup. McWatters was arrested the following day and confessed to the murders, only to later retract his confession.
Trials and Imprisonment
The courtroom lights bore down on McWatters in September 2006 as his trial commenced. Prosecutors painted him as a calculating predator who lured vulnerable women with the promise of drugs and alcohol. His defense team argued that McWatters' confession was a ploy for attention, denying his guilt in the killings. The jury was not convinced. On December 4, 2006, McWatters was found guilty of three counts of first-degree murder and sentenced to death.
For eight years, McWatters languished on death row until 2014, when a judge granted him a new trial, citing ineffective representation by his original defense team. In this new trial, McWatters pleaded no contest, resulting in his sentence being commuted to life imprisonment in 2015. The Salerno Strangler's story ended behind bars, with his death on September 9, 2024, at the Central Florida Reception Center in Orlando, Florida.
Sources
- The Palm Beach Post - Prosecution lays out case against McWatters
- WFLX.com - Eugene McWatters, man dubbed Salerno Strangler, sentenced to 3 life terms
- The Palm Beach Post - Eugene McWatters no stranger to police; The McWatters timeline
- The Palm Beach Post - Victim of December rape ID'd suspect from lineup
- Scripps Treasure Coast Newspapers - 'Salerno Strangler' seeks new trial, says original attorneys were ineffective
- The Palm Beach Post - 'Salerno Strangler' pleads no contest to first-degree murder
- Florida Department of Corrections
For further exploration of the chilling narrative, visit Wikipedia’s entry on Eugene McWatters.
No Recent News
No recent news articles found for this case. Check back later for updates.
No Evidence Submitted
No evidence found for this case. Be the first to submit evidence in the comments below.
Join the discussion
Loading comments...
First Rape Incident
Eugene McWatters rapes a homeless woman at a campsite.
First Murder
McWatters strangles and kills Jackie Bradley, dumping her body in a ditch.
Body Discovered
The body of Jackie Bradley is found by a jogger.
Second and Third Murders
McWatters strangles Christal Wiggins and Carrie Ann Caughey on the same day.
Caughey's Body Found
The body of Carrie Ann Caughey is discovered by passersby.
Wiggins' Body Found
The body of Christal Wiggins is discovered, linking her to the murders.
Arrest of McWatters
McWatters is arrested after being identified by a rape victim.
Sentenced to Death
McWatters is found guilty and sentenced to death for three murders.
Sentence Commuted
McWatters' death sentence is commuted to life imprisonment after a retrial.
Death in Prison
Eugene McWatters dies in prison.