Harry Edward Greenwell
Interstate Serial Killer Case
CLASSIFICATION: Serial Homicide
LOCATION
Indiana, Kentucky
TIME PERIOD
1987-1989
VICTIMS
3 confirmed
Harry Edward Greenwell, known as the I-65 Killer, was an American serial killer and rapist who committed at least three murders along Interstate 65 in Indiana and Kentucky between 1987 and 1989. The first victim, Vicki Lucille Heath, was sexually assaulted and shot on February 21, 1987, at a Super 8 Motel in Elizabethtown, Kentucky, with her body later discovered behind a dumpster. On March 3, 1989, Greenwell murdered two hotel clerks, Margaret Mary Gill and Jeanne Gilbert, at Days Inn locations in Merrillville and Remington, Indiana, respectively, after sexually assaulting them and stealing cash. Greenwell was linked to these crimes via DNA evidence in 2022, but he had already died of cancer on January 31, 2013, in Lansing, Iowa, before being identified as a serial killer.
Greenwell is believed to have committed more murders beyond the three confirmed cases, as some speculate he may have been responsible for additional unsolved cases along Interstate 65 during the late 1980s. Investigators have noted patterns in his modus operandi that suggest he targeted vulnerable women, particularly those in or near motels. There is also speculation regarding potential links to other serial killers active during the same timeframe, raising questions about possible connections in their methods or victim profiles.
The Enigmatic Trail of Harry Edward Greenwell: The I-65 Killer
The Birth of a Killer
Harry Edward Greenwell entered the world on December 9, 1944, in Louisville, Kentucky. Born to Paul and Dorothy Greenwell, Harry's early life was marked by the beginnings of a criminal path. At the age of 18, on January 17, 1963, he was arrested for armed robbery in his hometown. Just a few months later, on April 12, he was sentenced to two years in a reformatory, accompanied by five years of probation. The trouble didn't stop there. On February 23, 1965, Harry faced another arrest in Jefferson County, Kentucky, this time on a sodomy charge, only to be paroled from the Kentucky State Penitentiary four years later, in 1969.
The shadows of Harry's life deepened when tragedy struck in 1978. On April 28, his wife perished in a house fire in Vernon County, Wisconsin. Not long after, Harry found companionship again with a 39-year-old single mother, who had endured an abusive relationship. They married, and Harry, who had a daughter from a previous marriage, welcomed a son.
A Twisted Path
Harry's entanglements with the law were far from over. In 1982, he was arrested and subsequently imprisoned for burglary in Iowa. During this time, Harry twice managed to escape custody, only to be recaptured. His stints at Anamosa State Penitentiary and Kentucky State Reformatory ended with his release in 1983. Seeking a semblance of normalcy, Harry found work as a railroad worker, traversing the tracks of the Midwest.
Yet, beneath the facade of a hardworking man, a darker side simmered. On February 21, 1987, Harry's sinister nature emerged when he brutally assaulted and murdered Vicki Lucille Heath. The 41-year-old was found behind a dumpster at the Super 8 Motel in Elizabethtown, Kentucky. The gruesome scene revealed signs of a violent struggle, with a telephone ripped from the wall of the motel lobby.
A Trail of Blood
The violence didn't stop there. On March 3, 1989, Harry's murderous spree continued along the I-65 corridor. Margaret Mary "Peggy" Gill, a 24-year-old night auditor at the Days Inn in Merrillville, Indiana, was sexually assaulted and shot twice in the head. Her body was carelessly discarded in a back hallway, while $179 was stolen from the motel.
Four hours later, Harry claimed another life. Jeanne Gilbert, a 34-year-old part-time auditor at the Days Inn in Remington, Indiana, met a similar fate. She was assaulted and shot, her body abandoned near the roadway. The killer made off with $247. The same .22 caliber handgun was used in both murders, painting a clear picture of a calculated predator.
Harry's violence was not limited to murder. On January 2, 1990, a 21-year-old hotel clerk at the Columbus, Indiana Days Inn survived a harrowing attack. Working the night shift, she was sexually assaulted, stabbed, and robbed. Her vivid description of the assailant led to a composite sketch, and DNA evidence later connected this assault to the 1989 murders.
In 1991, another woman fell victim in Rochester, Minnesota. Like before, she survived, providing a description of a man with a lazy eye, clad in a flannel shirt and jeans. This attack, the only one occurring along Interstate 90, was officially linked to Harry in 2013 through DNA.
The Long Road to Justice
For years, these murders remained cold cases. It wasn't until 2008 that DNA evidence breathed new life into the investigation. By 2010, the Kentucky State Police confirmed what many feared: a serial killer was on the loose. The DNA linked these heinous crimes to Harry, and the killer's pattern suggested he was a seasonal worker, likely a truck driver or traveling salesman between 55 and 65 years old.
The breakthrough came when a DNA match with a close family member identified Harry as the killer. The Indiana State Police announced this revelation on April 5, 2022, stating there was a 99.999% probability of the match. They also indicated that Harry might have been involved in other violent crimes across the Midwest.
The Mask of Normalcy
Despite his dark deeds, Harry lived a seemingly ordinary life. In 1989, he faced arrests for a traffic violation and a domestic incident in La Crosse, Wisconsin. A month later, he violated a restraining order, earning a sentence of fifteen months' probation. His brushes with the law continued with an arrest in October 1998 for felony possession in Allamakee County, Iowa.
Retiring from the Canadian Pacific Railway in February 2010, Harry resided in a small town, where neighbors saw him as a kind and charismatic man. He was known for his generosity and passion for organic gardening, selling produce at farmers' markets. His interests spanned traveling, reading, wordsmithing, college sports, and horse racing.
However, on January 31, 2013, Harry's life came to an end as he succumbed to cancer in Lansing, Iowa. It wasn't until nearly a decade later that he was unmasked as the notorious I-65 Killer, leaving a chilling legacy of violence that haunted the Midwest for years.
Sources
For further reading, visit the original Wikipedia article.
No Recent News
No recent news articles found for this case. Check back later for updates.
No Evidence Submitted
No evidence found for this case. Be the first to submit evidence in the comments below.
Join the discussion
Loading comments...
First Murder
Harry Edward Greenwell sexually assaulted and shot Vicki Lucille Heath at a motel.
Double Murder
Greenwell killed two hotel clerks, Peggy Gill and Jeanne Gilbert, along I-65.
Survivor Attack
Greenwell attacked a hotel clerk in Columbus, Indiana, who survived and provided a description.
DNA Evidence Submitted
DNA from evidence of the murders was submitted for analysis, marking the start of renewed investigation.
Serial Killer Identified
Kentucky State Police announced that DNA linked the three murders to a serial killer.
Greenwell Dies
Harry Edward Greenwell died from cancer, before being identified as the I-65 Killer.
Identification Announced
Indiana State Police announced that DNA matched Greenwell to the cold case murders.
Harry Edward Greenwell, known as the I-65 Killer, was an American serial killer and rapist who committed at least three murders along Interstate 65 in Indiana and Kentucky between 1987 and 1989. The first victim, Vicki Lucille Heath, was sexually assaulted and shot on February 21, 1987, at a Super 8 Motel in Elizabethtown, Kentucky, with her body later discovered behind a dumpster. On March 3, 1989, Greenwell murdered two hotel clerks, Margaret Mary Gill and Jeanne Gilbert, at Days Inn locations in Merrillville and Remington, Indiana, respectively, after sexually assaulting them and stealing cash. Greenwell was linked to these crimes via DNA evidence in 2022, but he had already died of cancer on January 31, 2013, in Lansing, Iowa, before being identified as a serial killer.
Greenwell is believed to have committed more murders beyond the three confirmed cases, as some speculate he may have been responsible for additional unsolved cases along Interstate 65 during the late 1980s. Investigators have noted patterns in his modus operandi that suggest he targeted vulnerable women, particularly those in or near motels. There is also speculation regarding potential links to other serial killers active during the same timeframe, raising questions about possible connections in their methods or victim profiles.
The Enigmatic Trail of Harry Edward Greenwell: The I-65 Killer
The Birth of a Killer
Harry Edward Greenwell entered the world on December 9, 1944, in Louisville, Kentucky. Born to Paul and Dorothy Greenwell, Harry's early life was marked by the beginnings of a criminal path. At the age of 18, on January 17, 1963, he was arrested for armed robbery in his hometown. Just a few months later, on April 12, he was sentenced to two years in a reformatory, accompanied by five years of probation. The trouble didn't stop there. On February 23, 1965, Harry faced another arrest in Jefferson County, Kentucky, this time on a sodomy charge, only to be paroled from the Kentucky State Penitentiary four years later, in 1969.
The shadows of Harry's life deepened when tragedy struck in 1978. On April 28, his wife perished in a house fire in Vernon County, Wisconsin. Not long after, Harry found companionship again with a 39-year-old single mother, who had endured an abusive relationship. They married, and Harry, who had a daughter from a previous marriage, welcomed a son.
A Twisted Path
Harry's entanglements with the law were far from over. In 1982, he was arrested and subsequently imprisoned for burglary in Iowa. During this time, Harry twice managed to escape custody, only to be recaptured. His stints at Anamosa State Penitentiary and Kentucky State Reformatory ended with his release in 1983. Seeking a semblance of normalcy, Harry found work as a railroad worker, traversing the tracks of the Midwest.
Yet, beneath the facade of a hardworking man, a darker side simmered. On February 21, 1987, Harry's sinister nature emerged when he brutally assaulted and murdered Vicki Lucille Heath. The 41-year-old was found behind a dumpster at the Super 8 Motel in Elizabethtown, Kentucky. The gruesome scene revealed signs of a violent struggle, with a telephone ripped from the wall of the motel lobby.
A Trail of Blood
The violence didn't stop there. On March 3, 1989, Harry's murderous spree continued along the I-65 corridor. Margaret Mary "Peggy" Gill, a 24-year-old night auditor at the Days Inn in Merrillville, Indiana, was sexually assaulted and shot twice in the head. Her body was carelessly discarded in a back hallway, while $179 was stolen from the motel.
Four hours later, Harry claimed another life. Jeanne Gilbert, a 34-year-old part-time auditor at the Days Inn in Remington, Indiana, met a similar fate. She was assaulted and shot, her body abandoned near the roadway. The killer made off with $247. The same .22 caliber handgun was used in both murders, painting a clear picture of a calculated predator.
Harry's violence was not limited to murder. On January 2, 1990, a 21-year-old hotel clerk at the Columbus, Indiana Days Inn survived a harrowing attack. Working the night shift, she was sexually assaulted, stabbed, and robbed. Her vivid description of the assailant led to a composite sketch, and DNA evidence later connected this assault to the 1989 murders.
In 1991, another woman fell victim in Rochester, Minnesota. Like before, she survived, providing a description of a man with a lazy eye, clad in a flannel shirt and jeans. This attack, the only one occurring along Interstate 90, was officially linked to Harry in 2013 through DNA.
The Long Road to Justice
For years, these murders remained cold cases. It wasn't until 2008 that DNA evidence breathed new life into the investigation. By 2010, the Kentucky State Police confirmed what many feared: a serial killer was on the loose. The DNA linked these heinous crimes to Harry, and the killer's pattern suggested he was a seasonal worker, likely a truck driver or traveling salesman between 55 and 65 years old.
The breakthrough came when a DNA match with a close family member identified Harry as the killer. The Indiana State Police announced this revelation on April 5, 2022, stating there was a 99.999% probability of the match. They also indicated that Harry might have been involved in other violent crimes across the Midwest.
The Mask of Normalcy
Despite his dark deeds, Harry lived a seemingly ordinary life. In 1989, he faced arrests for a traffic violation and a domestic incident in La Crosse, Wisconsin. A month later, he violated a restraining order, earning a sentence of fifteen months' probation. His brushes with the law continued with an arrest in October 1998 for felony possession in Allamakee County, Iowa.
Retiring from the Canadian Pacific Railway in February 2010, Harry resided in a small town, where neighbors saw him as a kind and charismatic man. He was known for his generosity and passion for organic gardening, selling produce at farmers' markets. His interests spanned traveling, reading, wordsmithing, college sports, and horse racing.
However, on January 31, 2013, Harry's life came to an end as he succumbed to cancer in Lansing, Iowa. It wasn't until nearly a decade later that he was unmasked as the notorious I-65 Killer, leaving a chilling legacy of violence that haunted the Midwest for years.
Sources
For further reading, visit the original Wikipedia article.
No Recent News
No recent news articles found for this case. Check back later for updates.
No Evidence Submitted
No evidence found for this case. Be the first to submit evidence in the comments below.
Join the discussion
Loading comments...
First Murder
Harry Edward Greenwell sexually assaulted and shot Vicki Lucille Heath at a motel.
Double Murder
Greenwell killed two hotel clerks, Peggy Gill and Jeanne Gilbert, along I-65.
Survivor Attack
Greenwell attacked a hotel clerk in Columbus, Indiana, who survived and provided a description.
DNA Evidence Submitted
DNA from evidence of the murders was submitted for analysis, marking the start of renewed investigation.
Serial Killer Identified
Kentucky State Police announced that DNA linked the three murders to a serial killer.
Greenwell Dies
Harry Edward Greenwell died from cancer, before being identified as the I-65 Killer.
Identification Announced
Indiana State Police announced that DNA matched Greenwell to the cold case murders.