CASE FILE #BLPD-1937-01-01-001
Image Source: Genealogybank
Case header background
SOLVED

Rhonda Belle Martin

Female Serial Killer Case

CLASSIFICATION: Serial Homicide

LOCATION

Montgomery, Alabama

TIME PERIOD

1937-1951

VICTIMS

6 confirmed

CASE ACTIONS
AI ANALYSIS
OFFICIAL BRIEFING (FACT-BASED)

Rhonda Belle Martin, an American serial killer, was executed on October 11, 1957, at Kilby Correctional Facility in Alabama for the murder of her fourth husband, Claude Carroll Martin, in 1951. Over a span from 1937 to 1951, she was implicated in the poisoning deaths of her mother and five of her seven children, all under the age of 12, using rat poison as her method. Martin initially confessed to multiple murders but later recanted her admissions regarding two of her children. Her fifth husband, Ronald Martin, who was also her former stepson, survived an attempted poisoning, which ultimately led to the investigation of her crimes. Martin's execution marked her as the third and final woman electrocuted in Alabama prior to the 1972 Furman v. Georgia ruling.

COMMUNITY INTELLIGENCE (THEORY-BASED)

Rhonda Belle Martin is believed to have used rat poison as her preferred method for murdering her victims, which included her children and husbands. There is speculation that her confessions may have been coerced or influenced by mental health issues, as she later recanted some of them. Additionally, her case has led to discussions about the psychological motivations behind family annihilators and the societal implications of her actions.

FULL CASE FILE

The Dark Legacy of Rhonda Belle Martin

The Silent Waitress with a Deadly Secret

Rhonda Belle Martin was born on November 4, 1906, in Alabama to parents James Robert Thomley and Mary Frances Grimes. Her life seemed ordinary, marked by the unassuming role of a waitress in Montgomery, Alabama. Yet beneath this facade, Martin harbored a sinister secret that would eventually earn her the grim title of an American serial killer and family annihilator.

A Trail of Death

The path of destruction began in 1937, spanning until 1951, during which Rhonda orchestrated the deaths of six individuals, including her own family members. Her preferred weapon? Rat poison. The victims included her own mother, Mary Frances Grimes, and five of her seven children, all tragically losing their lives before reaching the age of twelve. Her fourth husband, Claude Carroll Martin, fell victim to her deadly machinations in 1951, a crime for which she would ultimately pay the ultimate price. Astonishingly, Ronald Martin, her former step-son and fifth husband, survived her poisoning attempt but was left a paraplegic, his condition drawing the attention of authorities and unraveling Martin’s web of deceit.

The Motive and Arrest

Prosecutors theorized that financial gain through insurance claims motivated Martin's deadly spree. However, this theory was tenuous at best, as she only collected enough to cover burial expenses and never admitted to such motivations. It was Ronald's mysterious illness, coupled with the suspicious deaths surrounding her, that led to her arrest in March 1956. During interrogation, Martin confessed to the murders of her mother, two husbands, and three of her children, though she denied involvement in the deaths of two other children.

The Trial: Justice for One

The trial focused on the murder of Claude Carroll Martin. Though she confessed to a slew of killings, the court only convicted her for Claude’s murder, which involved administering rat poison surreptitiously. The conviction for first-degree murder sealed her fate, sentencing her to death.

The Final Days

Martin’s time on death row was marked by a heart condition that prompted prison officials to withhold her execution date until it was imminent. As the date approached, her defense argued unsuccessfully for clemency, citing insufficient testing of her sanity. Transferred from Jefferson County Jail to Kilby Prison, where Alabama’s electric chair awaited her, Martin faced her mortality with a mix of resignation and defiance. Eight days before her execution, she gave an interview expressing a readiness to meet her fate, though admitting no one truly prepares for such an end.

On the eve of her execution, she indulged in a final meal of a hamburger, mashed potatoes, cinnamon rolls, and coffee. On October 11, 1957, as the clock struck midnight, Martin walked to the electric chair, clutching a Bible. She found solace in reciting the 23rd Psalm with the prison chaplain, maintaining composure despite quietly weeping.

Execution and Legacy

The execution, marred by a technical glitch, concluded at 12:16 am when Rhonda Belle Martin was pronounced dead. Her execution marked the end of an era in Alabama, as she became the third and final woman electrocuted before the pivotal Furman v. Georgia ruling, and the last until 2002.

In a note discovered posthumously, Martin expressed a wish for her body to be studied scientifically, hoping to uncover the root of her murderous impulses. However, instead of the scientific examination she desired, her remains were consigned to a funeral home in Montgomery.

Rhonda Belle Martin's story remains a chilling reminder of the darkness that can lurk behind the guise of normalcy, her name forever etched in the annals of infamy as a woman whose life spiraled into a tragic tale of death and deception.

Sources

For more information, visit the original article on Wikipedia.

RECENT DEVELOPMENTS

No Recent News

No recent news articles found for this case. Check back later for updates.

EVIDENCE BOARD

No Evidence Submitted

No evidence found for this case. Be the first to submit evidence in the comments below.

Discussion· Rhonda Belle Martin

Join the discussion

Loading comments...

CASE TIMELINE
Jan 1, 1937

First Murders

Rhonda Belle Martin begins her killing spree, allegedly poisoning her children.

Jan 1, 1951

Husband Murdered

Martin murders her fourth husband, Claude Carroll Martin, using rat poison.

Mar 1, 1956

Arrested

Rhonda Belle Martin is arrested after her fifth husband, Ronald Martin, survives poisoning.

Jun 5, 1956

Convicted

Martin is convicted of the murder of Claude Carroll Martin.

May 31, 1957

Execution Date Set

Martin's execution is scheduled for May 31, but is postponed.

Oct 11, 1957

Executed

Rhonda Belle Martin is executed by electrocution in Alabama.

SIMILAR CASES