The Incident (Conspiracy)
Royalist Kidnapping Conspiracy
CLASSIFICATION: Kidnapping
LOCATION
Edinburgh, Scotland
TIME PERIOD
October 1641
VICTIMS
3 confirmed
In October 1641, a Royalist conspiracy aimed to kidnap prominent Scottish nobles, specifically targeting the Marquis of Argyll, the Marquis of Hamilton, and the Earl of Lanark, amid rising tensions during the Wars of the Three Kingdoms. The plot, orchestrated by the Earl of Montrose, was thwarted when General Leslie received a tip-off from Sir John Hurry, leading to the nobles' flight from Edinburgh to Kinneil House. Following the failed kidnapping attempt, King Charles I denied involvement and was compelled to concede to the Covenanters' demands, including the abolition of episcopacy in Scotland and the appointment of Covenanting nobles to key positions. The investigation into the conspiracy remains ongoing, but the incident significantly weakened Royalist influence in Scotland.
The plot to kidnap Scottish nobles was believed to be orchestrated by Royalists who felt threatened by the growing influence of the Covenanters and sought to eliminate key figures like the Marquis of Argyll. Some speculate that Charles I may have had indirect approval of the plot, despite his public denial of involvement, as he was looking to strengthen his position against the Covenanters. Additionally, there are theories that internal rivalries among the Royalists, particularly between the Marquis of Hamilton and other factions, played a significant role in the conspiracy's development.
The Incident: A Royalist Conspiracy Unveiled
In the turbulent autumn of 1641, amidst the chaos of the Wars of the Three Kingdoms, a bold plot unfolded in Scotland that would threaten the stability of the realm. This Royalist conspiracy, known as "The Incident," aimed to kidnap a group of prominent Scottish nobles. These targets were not just any aristocrats; they were influential members of the Presbyterian Covenanter faction, staunch opponents of King Charles I's efforts to control the Scottish Church.
Background: Tensions in the Kingdom
The stage for this dramatic affair was set long before the conspiracy took root. Charles I, who ruled both England and Scotland, had recently been forced into a truce with the Covenanters, concluding the Bishops' Wars that had raged from 1639 to 1640. In August 1641, a peace treaty known as the Treaty of London was ratified, compelling Charles to travel to Edinburgh to solidify negotiations with the Scottish Parliament. The King sought to forge an alliance with Archibald Campbell, the Earl of Argyll and the de facto leader of the Covenanters, against the English Long Parliament. To secure this alliance, Charles elevated Argyll to the status of Marquis.
Meanwhile, the Marquis of Hamilton, a Royalist at heart, attempted to build a rapport with Argyll, a move that sowed seeds of unease among the Royalist faction. Charles's level of approval for this burgeoning friendship remained ambiguous, but it was clear that many Royalists felt their influence waning.
The Plot Unfolds
As September drew to a close, on the evening of the 29th, the tension in Edinburgh reached a boiling point. Lord Henry Ker, son of the Earl of Roxburgh, galloped into the city at the head of an armed retinue. His mission was bold and brash—he challenged Hamilton to a duel, branding him a traitor. While the confrontation ended without bloodshed, with Lord Ker retracting his accusation, it sparked whispers and intrigue among the Royalists, setting the stage for a conspiracy.
The mastermind behind this plot was James Graham, the Earl of Montrose, a Royalist rival of Argyll. Montrose had previously attempted to have Argyll charged with high treason. His new scheme was audacious: kidnap the Marquis of Argyll, the Marquis of Hamilton, and Hamilton's brother, the Earl of Lanark. The plan was to abduct them and spirit them away on a ship anchored at Leith.
The Plot Foiled
However, the conspiracy was not to succeed. On October 11th, a critical piece of intelligence reached General Leslie, the leader of the Covenanter army. The information came from Sir John Hurry, a Scottish soldier who had been approached to join the conspiracy. With the plot uncovered, Argyll, Hamilton, and Lanark were forced to flee Edinburgh. They sought refuge at Hamilton's estate, Kinneil House, near Bo'ness.
The following day, King Charles, now aware of the conspiracy's exposure, denied any involvement in the plot. However, the situation left him with little choice but to concede to the Covenanters' demands. This concession included agreeing to the abolition of episcopal governance in Scotland and appointing Covenanting nobles to the Privy Council of Scotland and other significant positions. With these agreements in place, Charles returned to England in November, where the specter of civil war loomed ever larger.
Conclusion
The Incident, though failing in its immediate objectives, stands as a testament to the fraught political landscape of 17th-century Britain. It revealed the intricate web of alliances and enmities that characterized the era and underscored the precarious position of King Charles I, caught between opposing forces within his kingdoms.
Sources
- Royle, Trevor (2006). Civil War: The Wars of the Three Kingdoms 1638–1660. Abacus. ISBN 978-0-349-11564-1.
- Plant, David. "BCW Project :: British Civil Wars, Commonwealth & Protectorate 1638-1660". BCW Project. Retrieved 4 July 2018.
- "Biography of Archibald Campbell, 1st Marquis of Argyll". 15 December 2006a.
- "Biography of Sir John Hurry". 26 March 2006b.
- "Timeline 1641". 17 April 2011.
- Taylor, James (1887). "The Campbells of Argyll". The Great Historic Families of Scotland (internet reprint ed.). Electric Scotland. Retrieved 18 March 2008.
For more on this historical intrigue, visit the original Wikipedia entry: The Incident (conspiracy).
No Recent News
No recent news articles found for this case. Check back later for updates.
No Evidence Submitted
No evidence found for this case. Be the first to submit evidence in the comments below.
Join the discussion
Loading comments...
Plot to Kidnap Nobles
A Royalist plot to kidnap Scottish nobles is hatched, targeting key Covenanter leaders.
Plot Discovered
General Leslie learns of the kidnapping plot and the targeted nobles flee to Kinneil House.
Charles Denies Involvement
King Charles I denies any involvement in the kidnapping plot and agrees to an investigation.
Covenanters' Demands Met
Charles I agrees to the Covenanters' demands, including the abolition of episcopacy in Scotland.
Return to England
Charles I returns to England to face the growing threat of civil war after conceding to the Covenanters.
In October 1641, a Royalist conspiracy aimed to kidnap prominent Scottish nobles, specifically targeting the Marquis of Argyll, the Marquis of Hamilton, and the Earl of Lanark, amid rising tensions during the Wars of the Three Kingdoms. The plot, orchestrated by the Earl of Montrose, was thwarted when General Leslie received a tip-off from Sir John Hurry, leading to the nobles' flight from Edinburgh to Kinneil House. Following the failed kidnapping attempt, King Charles I denied involvement and was compelled to concede to the Covenanters' demands, including the abolition of episcopacy in Scotland and the appointment of Covenanting nobles to key positions. The investigation into the conspiracy remains ongoing, but the incident significantly weakened Royalist influence in Scotland.
The plot to kidnap Scottish nobles was believed to be orchestrated by Royalists who felt threatened by the growing influence of the Covenanters and sought to eliminate key figures like the Marquis of Argyll. Some speculate that Charles I may have had indirect approval of the plot, despite his public denial of involvement, as he was looking to strengthen his position against the Covenanters. Additionally, there are theories that internal rivalries among the Royalists, particularly between the Marquis of Hamilton and other factions, played a significant role in the conspiracy's development.
The Incident: A Royalist Conspiracy Unveiled
In the turbulent autumn of 1641, amidst the chaos of the Wars of the Three Kingdoms, a bold plot unfolded in Scotland that would threaten the stability of the realm. This Royalist conspiracy, known as "The Incident," aimed to kidnap a group of prominent Scottish nobles. These targets were not just any aristocrats; they were influential members of the Presbyterian Covenanter faction, staunch opponents of King Charles I's efforts to control the Scottish Church.
Background: Tensions in the Kingdom
The stage for this dramatic affair was set long before the conspiracy took root. Charles I, who ruled both England and Scotland, had recently been forced into a truce with the Covenanters, concluding the Bishops' Wars that had raged from 1639 to 1640. In August 1641, a peace treaty known as the Treaty of London was ratified, compelling Charles to travel to Edinburgh to solidify negotiations with the Scottish Parliament. The King sought to forge an alliance with Archibald Campbell, the Earl of Argyll and the de facto leader of the Covenanters, against the English Long Parliament. To secure this alliance, Charles elevated Argyll to the status of Marquis.
Meanwhile, the Marquis of Hamilton, a Royalist at heart, attempted to build a rapport with Argyll, a move that sowed seeds of unease among the Royalist faction. Charles's level of approval for this burgeoning friendship remained ambiguous, but it was clear that many Royalists felt their influence waning.
The Plot Unfolds
As September drew to a close, on the evening of the 29th, the tension in Edinburgh reached a boiling point. Lord Henry Ker, son of the Earl of Roxburgh, galloped into the city at the head of an armed retinue. His mission was bold and brash—he challenged Hamilton to a duel, branding him a traitor. While the confrontation ended without bloodshed, with Lord Ker retracting his accusation, it sparked whispers and intrigue among the Royalists, setting the stage for a conspiracy.
The mastermind behind this plot was James Graham, the Earl of Montrose, a Royalist rival of Argyll. Montrose had previously attempted to have Argyll charged with high treason. His new scheme was audacious: kidnap the Marquis of Argyll, the Marquis of Hamilton, and Hamilton's brother, the Earl of Lanark. The plan was to abduct them and spirit them away on a ship anchored at Leith.
The Plot Foiled
However, the conspiracy was not to succeed. On October 11th, a critical piece of intelligence reached General Leslie, the leader of the Covenanter army. The information came from Sir John Hurry, a Scottish soldier who had been approached to join the conspiracy. With the plot uncovered, Argyll, Hamilton, and Lanark were forced to flee Edinburgh. They sought refuge at Hamilton's estate, Kinneil House, near Bo'ness.
The following day, King Charles, now aware of the conspiracy's exposure, denied any involvement in the plot. However, the situation left him with little choice but to concede to the Covenanters' demands. This concession included agreeing to the abolition of episcopal governance in Scotland and appointing Covenanting nobles to the Privy Council of Scotland and other significant positions. With these agreements in place, Charles returned to England in November, where the specter of civil war loomed ever larger.
Conclusion
The Incident, though failing in its immediate objectives, stands as a testament to the fraught political landscape of 17th-century Britain. It revealed the intricate web of alliances and enmities that characterized the era and underscored the precarious position of King Charles I, caught between opposing forces within his kingdoms.
Sources
- Royle, Trevor (2006). Civil War: The Wars of the Three Kingdoms 1638–1660. Abacus. ISBN 978-0-349-11564-1.
- Plant, David. "BCW Project :: British Civil Wars, Commonwealth & Protectorate 1638-1660". BCW Project. Retrieved 4 July 2018.
- "Biography of Archibald Campbell, 1st Marquis of Argyll". 15 December 2006a.
- "Biography of Sir John Hurry". 26 March 2006b.
- "Timeline 1641". 17 April 2011.
- Taylor, James (1887). "The Campbells of Argyll". The Great Historic Families of Scotland (internet reprint ed.). Electric Scotland. Retrieved 18 March 2008.
For more on this historical intrigue, visit the original Wikipedia entry: The Incident (conspiracy).
No Recent News
No recent news articles found for this case. Check back later for updates.
No Evidence Submitted
No evidence found for this case. Be the first to submit evidence in the comments below.
Join the discussion
Loading comments...
Plot to Kidnap Nobles
A Royalist plot to kidnap Scottish nobles is hatched, targeting key Covenanter leaders.
Plot Discovered
General Leslie learns of the kidnapping plot and the targeted nobles flee to Kinneil House.
Charles Denies Involvement
King Charles I denies any involvement in the kidnapping plot and agrees to an investigation.
Covenanters' Demands Met
Charles I agrees to the Covenanters' demands, including the abolition of episcopacy in Scotland.
Return to England
Charles I returns to England to face the growing threat of civil war after conceding to the Covenanters.