CASE FILE #BLPD-1985-08-22-001
Background collage mapBackground collage sketchBackground collage note
SOLVED

William Gollehon And Douglas Turner

Montana Serial Killers Case

CLASSIFICATION: Serial Homicide

LOCATION

Deer Lodge, Montana

TIME PERIOD

1985-1991

VICTIMS

6 confirmed

CASE ACTIONS
AI ANALYSIS
OFFICIAL BRIEFING (FACT-BASED)

On September 22, 1991, a violent riot at Montana State Prison resulted in the murders of five inmates by serial killers William Jay Gollehon and Douglas Duane Turner, who were already serving sentences for previous homicides. The incident led to the deaths of Gerald Pileggi, Vern Baker, Edmund Davidson, Gary Evans, and Ernest Holliday, with Gollehon and Turner later receiving death sentences and multiple life sentences for their roles in these murders. Gollehon, born in 1964, remains on death row, while Turner, born around 1971, died by suicide in 2003. The riot also left eight other inmates injured, and additional convictions were made against thirteen other prisoners involved in the chaos. The case highlights the severe implications of prison violence and the challenges of managing inmate populations.

COMMUNITY INTELLIGENCE (THEORY-BASED)

William Gollehon and Douglas Turner are believed to have committed their murders in a chaotic environment during a prison riot, leading to speculation that the violence was exacerbated by the conditions within the prison. Some theorize that their prior violent histories contributed to their actions during the riot, suggesting a pattern of escalating violence among inmates. Additionally, there are discussions about the possibility of prison staff negligence or failure to manage the riot effectively, which may have allowed the killings to occur.

FULL CASE FILE

The Dark Chronicles of William Gollehon and Douglas Turner

In the shadowy corridors of Montana's criminal history, two names resonate with chilling infamy: William Jay Gollehon and Douglas Duane Turner. Together, they orchestrated a series of murders that left an indelible mark on the Montana State Prison system. Their tale is one of violence, chaos, and death, culminating in a prison riot that would forever alter the lives of those involved.

The Men Behind the Murders

Born in 1964 in Washington, U.S., William Gollehon's criminal path was marked by deliberate homicide, kidnapping, and burglary. His crimes spanned from 1985 to 1991, leaving seven victims dead—six of whom he killed in collaboration with Turner. Douglas Turner, born around 1971 in Glendive, Montana, shared a similarly grim fate. By the time of his death on July 8, 2003, in Deer Lodge, Montana, Turner had been convicted of nine counts of deliberate homicide and kidnapping. Between them, Gollehon and Turner were responsible for the deaths of ten individuals.

A Trail of Bloodshed

Gollehon's first known victim was Brenda Bargas, a 34-year-old woman murdered on August 22, 1985, in Billings, Montana. Turner's killing spree began on November 19, 1987, in Glendive, Montana, where he brutally ended the lives of James Brooks, Ora Brooks, and Sharon Brooks.

But it was their joint actions inside the walls of Montana State Prison that truly shocked the nation. On September 2, 1990, the duo murdered Gerald Pileggi, setting the stage for a violent chapter in the prison's history. Then, on September 22, 1991, during a riot, they took the lives of Vern Baker, 24; Edmund Davidson, 33; Gary Evans, 26; Ernest Holliday, 38; and Ernest Mazurkiewicz, 32.

The Montana Prison Riot

The riot of September 22, 1991, was a bloodbath that resulted in the deaths of five inmates and left eight others injured. Thirteen prisoners were later convicted for their roles in the riot. Among them were death row inmate Terry Langford, executed in 1998 for his original crime, and Robert Wild and Gary Cox, both convicted of five counts of deliberate homicide, burglary, and kidnapping. Robert Close faced similar charges, although he was found guilty of sexual intercourse without consent instead of kidnapping. Reed Nevins, despite being convicted of similar crimes, faced four fewer homicide charges.

Other inmates involved included Kenneth Allen and Joseph Milinovich, who admitted to mitigated deliberate homicide, a lesser charge in Montana. Milinovich also confessed to burglary. The remaining participants—Ben Cook, Harold Gleed, Daniel Lopez, Steve Ritchson, Scott Seelye, and Brian Spray—were convicted of various crimes, including homicide, burglary, rape, assault, and rioting.

One of the deceased from the riot, Ernest Mazurkiewicz, had a dark past of his own. In July 1989, he participated in the robbery and murder of Larry Beckwith in Broadwater County, alongside Joseph Milinovich. This twist of fate saw Milinovich later involved in the riot that claimed Mazurkiewicz's life.

The Aftermath

For their part in the riot, Gollehon and Turner were sentenced to death for Pileggi's murder and received life sentences for the five additional murders in 1991. Gollehon was also convicted of kidnapping and burglary, while Turner was convicted of kidnapping alone. Turner's story ended in tragedy when he died by suicide in 2003. Meanwhile, Gollehon remains on death row, his fate hanging in the balance.

The riot's repercussions extended beyond the prison walls. In 2008, Daniel Lopez, one of the riot participants, escaped Montana while on parole, sparking a nationwide manhunt. Two years later, U.S. Marshals captured him in Albuquerque, New Mexico.

Unfolding Justice

The story of William Gollehon and Douglas Turner is a grim reminder of the dark potential that lies within the human soul. Their legacy is one of terror and violence, leaving behind a trail of broken lives and shattered communities. As the wheels of justice continue to turn, the memory of their heinous acts serves as a cautionary tale for generations to come.

Sources

For further reading and references, please visit the original Wikipedia article.

RECENT DEVELOPMENTS

No Recent News

No recent news articles found for this case. Check back later for updates.

EVIDENCE BOARD

No Evidence Submitted

No evidence found for this case. Be the first to submit evidence in the comments below.

Discussion· William Gollehon And Douglas Turner

Join the discussion

Loading comments...

CASE TIMELINE
Aug 22, 1985

First Murder Committed

William Gollehon murders Brenda Bargas in Billings.

Nov 19, 1987

Multiple Murders by Turner

Douglas Turner murders James, Ora, and Sharon Brooks in Glendive.

Sep 2, 1990

Gerald Pileggi Murdered

Gollehon and Turner murder Gerald Pileggi in Deer Lodge.

Sep 22, 1991

Prison Riot Murders

During a riot, Gollehon and Turner kill five inmates at Montana State Prison.

Sep 23, 1991

Investigation Launched

Authorities begin investigation into the prison riot and murders.

Jan 1, 1992

Arrests Made

William Gollehon and Douglas Turner are arrested and charged with multiple murders.

Jan 1, 1993

Sentencing

Gollehon and Turner sentenced to death and life imprisonment for their crimes.

Jul 8, 2003

Turner Dies

Douglas Turner dies by suicide in prison.

Jan 1, 2023

Gollehon on Death Row

William Gollehon remains on death row for his crimes.

SIMILAR CASES