CASE FILE #BLPD-1903-08-13-001
Image Source: Wikipedia
Case header background
SOLVED

Winfield Massacre

Mass Shooting Incident

CLASSIFICATION: Mass Murder

LOCATION

Winfield, Kansas

TIME PERIOD

August 13, 1903

VICTIMS

9 confirmed

CASE ACTIONS
AI ANALYSIS
OFFICIAL BRIEFING (FACT-BASED)

On August 13, 1903, at approximately 9:00 p.m. in Winfield, Kansas, a mass shooting occurred during a concert held by W.H. Caman and his military band, attended by an estimated 2,000 to 5,000 people. The shooter, 35-year-old Gilbert A. Twigg, opened fire from a nearby alley using a double-barreled shotgun, resulting in the deaths of nine individuals and injuries to at least 25 others before he committed suicide. Twigg, a local miller and Army veteran, had a history of personal grievances, as revealed in letters found at his boarding room, which expressed feelings of alienation and a desire for revenge against the community. The incident is noted as a precursor to modern mass shootings and remains a significant event in the history of gun violence in the United States.

COMMUNITY INTELLIGENCE (THEORY-BASED)

Gilbert A. Twigg's actions during the Winfield massacre are often theorized to stem from his mental instability, as he was known locally as "Crazy Twigg" despite being perceived as harmless by his community. Some speculate that his military background and experiences may have contributed to his violent outburst, suggesting a possible link between trauma and his eventual breakdown. Additionally, the indiscriminate nature of the attack has led to discussions about it being a precursor to modern mass shootings, highlighting concerns over societal factors that may lead individuals to commit such acts.

FULL CASE FILE

The Winfield Massacre: A Prelude to Modern Tragedy

In the quiet town of Winfield, Kansas, a night meant for music and community turned into one of terror and tragedy. On the evening of August 13, 1903, beneath the dimming summer sky, a violent act unfolded that would etch itself into the annals of American history as an early harbinger of mass shootings.

The Fateful Night

As the clock neared 9:00 p.m., the streets of Winfield buzzed with the eager anticipation of a musical evening. W.H. Caman and his military band were prepared to entertain a crowd that numbered between 2,000 to 5,000 people. The gathering was a quintessential slice of small-town Americana, taking place at the bustling corner of Ninth Street and Main Street. Unbeknownst to the attendees, Gilbert A. Twigg, a 35-year-old former Army veteran, lay in wait in a nearby alley behind the city's Odd Fellows building.

Armed with a 12-gauge Dumoulin & Co. double-barreled shotgun, Twigg emerged from the shadows, unleashing a fusillade of shots into the unsuspecting crowd. The chaos was immediate and devastating. Six individuals succumbed to their injuries on the scene or shortly thereafter, while three more would tragically pass away in the hospital. The violent outburst did not end with these victims, as at least 25 others were wounded in the mayhem.

The carnage came to a grim conclusion when two concert-goers bravely attempted to disarm Twigg. In response, he turned a .32-caliber H&R 6-shot revolver on himself, ending his life with a final, fatal shot.

Gilbert A. Twigg: A Troubled Soul

Gilbert A. Twigg's life story is one marked by service and struggle. Born in Maryland in 1868, Twigg's early years saw him working as a miller and serving his country during the Philippine–American War and the American occupation of Cuba. Before enlisting, he had resided in various locations including Great Falls, Montana, the Territory of New Mexico, and Burden, Kansas. By the time he settled in Winfield, he was employed by Baden Mills and had garnered the nickname "Crazy Twigg." Despite this moniker, many locals regarded him as harmless, agreeable, and industrious.

Yet, beneath this exterior lay a man burdened by personal turmoil. In his boarding room, officers discovered a letter penned by Twigg, addressed to the public. The letter revealed his deep-seated bitterness over a breakup that had occurred nearly a decade prior. It also expressed his yearning to "get even" with the people of Winfield, whom he accused of shunning him and meddling in his affairs. Another letter, dated September 1, 1902, was addressed to a friend in Montana. In it, Twigg lamented his solitary life, writing, "it would have been much better for me if I had gotten married and settled down as you have done—I have no doubt that you are very happy, while I am not."

The Victims

The tragic events of that night claimed the lives of nine individuals, each with their own stories and futures cut abruptly short:

  • James Dawson Billiter, 23
  • William F. "Bog" Bowman, 55
  • Otis Niles Carter, 24
  • Roy C. Davis, 15
  • Elmer E. Farnsworth, 35
  • Sterling Race, 28
  • Everett Ridgeway
  • Port B. Smith, 19
  • Charles Russell Thomas, 32

A Legacy of Violence

The Winfield massacre stands as a chilling precursor to the modern phenomenon of mass shootings. In an era when such violence was uncommon, it shocked the nation and left an indelible mark on the collective consciousness.

The motivations behind Twigg's actions, rooted in personal grievances and perceived injustices, echo eerily in the narratives of many subsequent mass shootings. As such, the tragedy in Winfield serves as a somber reminder of the destructive potential of unresolved personal conflicts and societal alienation.

Sources

For further reading and reference, please consult the following sources:

These sources provide comprehensive accounts of the events and aftermath of the Winfield massacre.

RECENT DEVELOPMENTS

No Recent News

No recent news articles found for this case. Check back later for updates.

EVIDENCE BOARD

No Evidence Submitted

No evidence found for this case. Be the first to submit evidence in the comments below.

Discussion· Winfield Massacre

Join the discussion

Loading comments...

CASE TIMELINE
Aug 13, 1903

Mass Shooting at Concert

Gilbert A. Twigg opens fire at a concert, killing nine.

Aug 13, 1903

Twigg Commits Suicide

After shooting, Twigg takes his own life with a revolver.

Aug 14, 1903

Initial Reports of Casualties

Reports confirm six dead at the scene, with more injured.

Aug 19, 1903

Victims' Funerals

Funerals held for victims, drawing community attention.

Aug 20, 1903

Public Outcry

Local newspapers report on the massacre, sparking outrage.

Aug 20, 1903

Investigation Findings

Police find letters from Twigg revealing his motives.

Aug 21, 1903

Community Vigil

Residents hold a vigil for the victims of the massacre.

Dec 1, 1903

Case Closure

Authorities conclude investigation, deeming case closed.

SIMILAR CASES