ANALYZING EVIDENCE

Processing case files...

The Investigation in Your Pocket

Get our dedicated mobile apps for iOS and Android to continue your investigation on the go.

Bloody Likely

Case file article licenses vary by case and are shown in each Full Case File section.

Sources remain the property of their respective owners.

About Editorial Standards Corrections Original Case Files Privacy Policy Terms of Service Content License

Original Case FilesPage 2

Explore original Bloody Likely case files built from cited sources, timelines, public records, archival reporting, and documented facts.

Showing page 2 of 10

Original Bloody Likely Case Files

Original Bloody Likely Case File

Christine Chubbuck

A television news presenter shot herself on live broadcast during WXLT-TV's Suncoast Digest on July 15, 1974, in Sarasota, Florida. The victim, Christine Chubbuck, had struggled with long-term depression and had previously attempted an overdose; she scripted the broadcast to include a line announcing an "attempted suicide" before drawing a .38-caliber revolver and shooting herself. The station faded to black and Chubbuck was taken to Sarasota Memorial Hospital where she was later pronounced dead; the on-air recording was retained privately and its existence was later confirmed. The case is not a criminal investigation: responsibility is established as an on-air suicide and the matter is considered closed with the victim identified as the actor in the event.

Sarasota, Florida

6 sources cited

Updated July 15, 2026

Sarasota, Florida

1 victims · Solved

Original Bloody Likely Case File

William Bullock (Inventor)

An inventor was fatally injured while making adjustments to a web rotary printing press in early April 1867 in Philadelphia; his leg was caught and crushed by the machine, gangrene developed, and he died during an amputation on April 12, 1867. The inventor was William Bullock, noted for 1863 improvements to the rotary printing press, and the press involved was being installed for the Philadelphia Public Ledger. The case is a documented accidental death and is closed; the key evidence includes the eyewitness account of the accident, the chronology of injury to death, and contemporary patents and installation records for the machine.

Pittsburgh

6 sources cited

Updated July 15, 2026

Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

1 victims · closed

Original Bloody Likely Case File

Charles Stevens (Serial Killer)

Charles Arnett Stevens, known as "The I-580 Killer," committed a series of shootings along Interstate 580 in California between April 3 and July 27, 1989, resulting in the deaths of four individuals and injuries to several others. He was apprehended on July 27, 1989, and subsequently sentenced to death for his crimes. Stevens is currently incarcerated at San Quentin State Prison, where he remains on death row.

California

2 sources cited

Updated July 13, 2026

Oakland, California

4 victims · Solved

Original Bloody Likely Case File

Travis (Chimpanzee)

A 200-pound pet chimpanzee named Travis violently attacked and severely mauled 55-year-old Charla Nash on February 16, 2009, in Stamford, Connecticut, causing catastrophic facial and hand injuries and leaving her blind and disfigured. The animal’s owner, Sandra Herold, attempted to stop the attack and emergency police shot and killed the chimpanzee at the scene; Travis’ head tested negative for rabies and toxicology later showed Xanax in his system. The victim underwent extensive surgeries, later receiving a partial face transplant, and sued the owner’s estate, which settled; state and federal legislative efforts to restrict primate ownership intensified after the incident. The chimpanzee was cremated and necropsy confirmed he had been stabbed and was significantly overweight; the case is closed with the attacking animal deceased.

Stamford CT

6 sources cited

Updated July 12, 2026

Stamford, Connecticut, U.S.

1 victims · Solved

Original Bloody Likely Case File

Death By Vending Machine

A series of accidental deaths and injuries occurred when heavy vending machines were rocked or tilted and toppled onto victims. Documented incidents span at least from 1978 to 1995 with the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission recording at least 37 deaths and 113 injuries; the U.S. military and manufacturers subsequently began applying warning labels in the late 1980s and 1990s. The victims were overwhelmingly male and incidents typically involved attempts to obtain product, change, or free items. There is no single perpetrator; this is an ongoing public safety/accident hazard addressed through labeling and industry warnings.

United States

5 sources cited

Updated July 11, 2026

Unknown

37 victims · Cold Case

Original Bloody Likely Narrative Synthesis

Salad Oil Scandal

In 1963, the Salad Oil Scandal emerged as a significant corporate fraud case involving the Allied Crude Vegetable Oil Company, owned by Anthony "Tino" De Angelis, in New Jersey. De Angelis fraudulently inflated the company's inventory of salad oil, securing approximately $180 million in loans by falsely presenting ships filled with water as containing salad oil, deceiving banks and investors. The scandal unraveled when the anticipated Russian soybean market failed to materialize, leading to a drastic drop in soybean prices and exposing the fraudulent activities. De Angelis was ultimately convicted of fraud and conspiracy, serving seven years in prison before his release in 1972. The incident caused substantial financial losses to major corporations, including American Express and Bank of America, and has since been compared to later financial crises due to its impact on lending practices.

New Jersey

4 sources cited

Updated July 11, 2026

New Jersey, United States

3 victims · Solved

Original Bloody Likely Case File

Jared Fogle

A prominent Subway spokesman exchanged and received child pornography and paid for sex with underage victims, leading to a federal investigation and arrest. The investigation, prompted in part by the arrest of an associate, produced digital evidence recovered from the associate that tied the defendant to explicit images and communications. He was indicted, pleaded guilty to child pornography and child sex tourism charges in 2015, and was sentenced to 15 years and eight months in federal prison. The defendant remains incarcerated and was ordered to pay restitution and register as a sex offender for life.

Indiana

9 sources cited

Updated July 11, 2026

Zionsville, Indiana, U.S.

14 victims · Solved

Original Bloody Likely Case File

2017 Eaton Township Weis Markets Shooting

A supermarket employee carried out a fatal shooting at the Weis Markets in Eaton Township on June 8, 2017, killing three coworkers and then fatally shooting himself. The perpetrator was Randy Robert Stair, a 24-year-old longtime employee who left extensive online posts, videos, and files documenting his planning and motives. Investigators recovered shotguns, digital media, notebooks, and a series of recorded 'suicide tapes' and journal entries from his residence. The case is closed with the perpetrator deceased and responsibility established by evidence and his published materials.

Pennsylvania

16 sources cited

Updated July 11, 2026

Eaton Township, Pennsylvania

3 victims · Solved

Original Bloody Likely Case File

Great Molasses Flood

A large molasses storage tank at the Purity Distilling/USIA facility on Commercial Street burst on January 15, 1919, releasing a fast-moving wave of molasses that killed 21 people and injured about 150. The tank failure occurred in Boston's North End after unseasonably warm weather and additions of warmed molasses; rescuers from nearby ships, police, Red Cross and military personnel recovered victims amid viscous, sticky conditions. A class-action suit found the company responsible after multi-year hearings and the company paid damages; the site was later commemorated and modern building-code and oversight changes followed. Key evidence included eyewitness accounts of the rupture, engineering analyses of thin and brittle steel and flawed rivets, and later scientific and engineering studies confirming rapid flow and cooling behaviour.

Boston

10 sources cited

Updated July 11, 2026

Boston, Massachusetts

21 victims · Solved

Original Bloody Likely Case File

D.C. Sniper Attacks

The D.C. sniper attacks were a series of coordinated shootings that occurred from October 2 to October 24, 2002, across the Washington metropolitan area, resulting in the deaths of 10 individuals and injuries to 3 others. The perpetrators, John Allen Muhammad and Lee Boyd Malvo, were apprehended and subsequently convicted; Muhammad was executed in 2009, while Malvo is serving multiple life sentences. The case is considered solved.

Washington D.C.

6 sources cited

Updated July 11, 2026

Washington, D.C.

17 victims · Solved

Original Bloody Likely Narrative Synthesis

2009 Collier Township Shooting

A gunman entered an LA Fitness gym aerobics class in Collier Township on August 4, 2009, turned off the lights and opened fire, killing three women and wounding nine before killing himself. The attacker was identified as 48-year-old George Alfred Sodini, who left writings and online posts expressing deep misogyny and resentment over social rejection. Investigators recovered two 9mm Glocks used in the shooting, an unused .32 pistol, and evidence he shot himself with a .45 Colt revolver; his motive is characterized as misogyny and rage. The case ended with the perpetrator dead and therefore no criminal prosecution; victims and families pursued civil claims and related legal actions followed.

Collier Township

4 sources cited

Updated July 11, 2026

Collier Township, Pennsylvania, U.S.

3 victims · Solved

Source-Backed Case Summary

Elliot Rodger

On May 23, 2014 in Isla Vista, California, Elliot Rodger stabbed three people in his apartment and then carried out a shooting and vehicle-ramming rampage that killed six UCSB students and injured fourteen others before fatally shooting himself. Rodger prepared a 137-page manifesto and uploaded videos announcing his intent to "punish" women and sexually active men; police later recovered multiple handguns, over 500 rounds of ammunition, and knives in his vehicle and apartment. The attacker was identified (and died by suicide at the scene), no criminal trial occurred, and investigators cited online radicalization, misogynistic motive, and missed warning signs as central to the case. Key evidence includes Rodger's manifesto, recorded videos, his firearm and ammunition cache, and forensic examination of the stab and gunshot victims and his crashed BMW.

Isla Vista

3 sources cited

Updated July 11, 2026

Isla Vista, California, U.S.

6 victims · Solved